- Research article
- Open Access
- Open Peer Review
A simple and short microbiology practical improves undergraduate nursing students’ awareness of bacterial traits and ability to avoid spreading infections
BMC Medical Educationvolume 19, Article number: 53 (2019)
Nurses are responsible for implementing appropriate measures to reduce hospital infections, especially with multidrug resistant bacteria, so nursing students should learn about microbiology. This helps them to understand bacterial dissemination and infectious disease control. Because of tight schedules, however, its teaching is limited in undergraduate nursing classes in Japan. We therefore tested whether a simple short practical session in a microbiology class could help to improve undergraduate nursing students’ awareness of bacterial traits and how to prevent infections.
This study involved second-grade nursing students (n = 76). Two short practical sessions (a total of 3 h, across 2 days) were used to assess the effectiveness of washing or disinfection on hand bacteria in a 16-class microbiology course (total class time was 24 h, plus an exam). Hand bacteria were sampled on LB agar plates with orientation during the first half-day, and the plates examined for colonies with distinct color or morphological traits, and discussed, in the second session, a week later. Questionnaires before and after the exercise were used to assess changes in awareness of unseen bacteria inhabiting around us connecting bacterial traits and how to prevent infections.
The results showed that the practical increased the nursing students’ awareness of fomites (utensils) (p = 0.0115), fomites (contact-based) (p = 0.0016), habitats (body surface) (p = 0.0127), action facilitating hospital infection (p = 0.0166), and changes in physical condition caused by bacterial infections (p = 0.0136). There were no changes in word associations (p = 0.627) or habitats (inside body) (p = 0.308). Difficulty score, which is an element in questionnaire psychometric properties, tended to be close to the expected score through the practical, but not statistical significant. In addition, regardless of before or after practical, Cronbach α score, which is an indicator of the reliability among items of multi-choice questions, showed > 0.8, indicating validity of evaluation items. Thus, the student’s awareness of unseen bacteria inhabiting around us was significantly increased as compared to those before practical in microbiology class.
The simple short practical effectively improved nursing students’ awareness of unseen bacteria inhabiting around us in microbiology course, useful for even tight teaching schedules.
Precautions taken during contact between patients and medical staff and the cleanliness of high-contact surfaces in hospitals are critically important in controlling hospital-acquired infections (HAIs) . Bacterial contamination of surfaces in hospitals surfaces occurs through contact with a range of individuals including visitors, patients, and staff, despite extensive measures to promote cleanliness, including determination of aerobic colony-forming units or detection of ATP on surfaces [2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10]. Nurses are principally responsible for implementing appropriate measures to reduce hospital infections, especially with multidrug resistant bacteria . Improving awareness of unseen bacteria ubiquitously inhabiting around us is directly linked to controlling HAIs. Meanwhile, the contents of microbiology courses in nursing classes are generally based on knowledge because the course lacks in practical work such as forming bacterial culture or colony observation. It is therefore reasonable for nursing students to learn about its practice, at an early stage in their training, undoubtedly helping them to recognize unseen bacteria potentially transmitting everywhere via medical staff or fomites. However there is no consensus about the best way to teach management of standard precautions and precautions based on disease transmission mechanisms to nursing students or other health care students .
Although the homogeneous and systematic education system promises to provide high quality classes for those students , there is, however, a concern about the poor integration of practice with critical thinking, because of busy class schedules and a focus on theory in lessons . Unfortunately, microbiology course is no exception to this, and inadequate awareness of bacterial traits and how to protect against infection, in particular lacking practical work, is a serious issue. It is therefore considered important to provide effective practical training in microbiology course for nursing students at an early stage of their education, to help them to recognize unseen bacteria around us and understand how to avoid spreading infection. No adequate practical demonstrations in microbiology course have been provided for nursing students, especially undergraduates. Furthermore, it is well accepted that a theoretical framework that can foster experiential learning consisting of a cycle with concrete experience, reflective observation, abstract conceptualization and active experimentation, can generate awareness strongly .
In this study, we therefore developed a short and simple practical program (a total of 3 h, over 2 days) that is easily embedded in microbiology courses (which cover a total of 24 h class time plus an exam, and a period of 16 days). We used questionnaires to assess whether this practical program could improve undergraduate nursing students’ awareness of bacterial traits and how to avoid spreading infection.
The study involved second-grade nursing students (n = 76) from the Faculty of Medicine (Health Sciences), at Hokkaido University. All elements were part of the regular microbiology course.
Figure 1 shows the design of the study. Two short practical sessions (in total, only 3 h, over 2 days, 7 days apart) were used to demonstrate the effectiveness of hand hygiene by washing hand with or without disinfectants (70% alcohol or waterless antiseptic agent) on eliminating hand bacteria. These sessions were part of a basic microbiology course for the nursing students (16 classes totaling 24 h, over the period from April to July, plus an exam). The course covered an introduction, bacterial ecology, structure, growth and metabolism, viruses, fungi, protozoa, disinfection and sterilizing, antibiotics, infections and host defenses, and infectious diseases. The sampling of hand bacteria on an LB (Luria-Bertani) agar plate with orientation took place one day (Fig. 1, “Day 1”), and seven days’ later, the students examined the plates for colonies with distinct color or morphological traits, then discussed their findings (Fig. 1, “Day 2”). For the nursing students, questionnaires (see below) were used to assess changes in awareness of microbiology before and after the practical sessions.
LB agar plate culture and colony observation
All the agar plates were cultured for 7 days at room temperature. After being carefully sealed with laboratory tape, the cultured plates were carefully observed in the lecture room to assess the color, size, gloss, and number of colonies. Since the sessions took place in a general lecture room, which did not meet specified biosafety levels, the plates could not be opened for observation. It was, however, considered more convenient to carry out the practical in a general lecture room.
Questionnaires and data expressions
As mentioned above, the questionnaires for the nursing students were administered twice, before and after the practical sessions. The questionnaire included seven general questions (Q1–7), each with eight answer options. The questions covered various aspects of bacteria including word associations, changes in physical condition as a result of infection, fomites (utensil or contact-based material), bacterial habitats (body surface or inside), and actions facilitating hospital infections (see Table 1). Each of the questions allowed multiple answers. For each question, data were expressed as “Improved value Δ%”, calculated as “rate after the practical”−“rate before the practical” . Also, cumulative score of individual students for each of the items in questionnaire were used for estimating psychometric properties (See below).
Estimation of psychometric properties including score mean, score distribution, Cronbach α score, and difficulty index (DI)
First of all, score mean and its distribution were calculated for estimating Cronbach α score, which is an indicator for estimating the reliability of multi-choice questions based on comparing the score of distribution among questionnaire’s items . The Cronbach α score were estimated by a protocol with an equation [α = (k/k–1)(1–sum of variances of all items/total test variance)] as described previously . In this equation,“k” shows the number of items in questionnaire. Also, to confirm the validity of “difficulty” among items in questionnaire, DI was calculated by a protocol with an equation (number of expected answers/number of all student’s answers) as described previously , and then compared among expected answer score, pre-practical score, and after-practical score. All calculations were conducted using Excel for Mac (2015) with Statcel3C.
Comparison between “rate after the practical” and “rate before the practical” was performed using statistical analysis with two-way ANOVA. Comparison among DIs was conducted using a Bonferroni/Dunn test. Additionally, diffract score(score distribution) was estimated using a function with VAR(x) installed into Excel. P-value of less than 0.05 was considered significant. Cronbach’s α score of more than 0.8 was considered as having significant validity.
The practical’s impact on awareness of unseen bacteria around us among nursing students
To assess whether the practical program had an impact on awareness of unseen bacteria inhabiting around us among the nursing students, we compared their awareness before and after the practical sessions. Figure 2 shows that awareness was significantly increased of fomites (utensils) (p = 0.0115), fomites (contact-based) (p = 0.0016), habitats (body surface) (p = 0.0127), actions facilitating hospital infection (p = 0.0166), and physical changes in condition caused by bacterial infections (p = 0.0136). There were no changes in word associations (p = 0.627) or habitats (inside body) (p = 0.308). Thus, the results therefore indicated that even a simple short practical program in microbiology can have a strong impact on increasing awareness about microbiology in particular in terms of unseen bacteria inhabiting around us among nursing students.
Validity of items in questionnaire on estimating the changes in awareness via practical
To verify whether the changes in awareness were a meaningful improvement among nursing students, we estimated psychometric properties including mean, distribution of scores, Cronbach α score and DI. As shown in Fig. 3 (above panel), Cronbach α score on the questionnaires showed > 0.8 (before practical, 0.904; after practical, 0.890), indicating validity of evaluation items in questionnaire. Furthermore, we found that DI tended to be close to the expected score through the practical, but not statistical significant. The result was corresponded to those of awareness in the questionnaires, verifying the items in questionnaire on estimating the changes in awareness via practical.
The undergraduate education system for nurses in Japan, including in microbiology course, lacks integration of practical sessions with critical thinking, because of busy class schedules and a focus on theoretical teaching [13, 14]. Nurses, however, play a key role in preventing hospital-acquired infections, and it is therefore important to provide effective microbiological practical sessions for nursing students at an early stage in their education. We developed a short, simple practical program that is easily embedded in a standard microbiology course. We used questionnaires to assess whether the practical could be useful in improving undergraduate nursing students’ awareness of bacterial traits and how to prevent infections. We found that a simple short practical program in microbiology course can have a strong impact on increasing awareness about unseen bacteria inhabiting around us among nursing students. This suggests that it could be used even in classes with tight schedules, and could therefore be an appropriate measure to help reduce hospital infections.
At this stage in their training, the nursing students had learned only basic chemistry, biology and techniques in nursing care, so had limited knowledge and skills. The practical therefore simply consisted of hand sampling on an LB agar plate, and the observation of colonies formed on the plates. No specified biosafety laboratory room or microscopes were required, which meant that the practical could take place in a general lecture room. The practical took only 3 h across two sessions, so the time consumption was not excessive. It also required very little preparation, because each student only required two agar plates, so the burden on staff was limited, and the expense was low (less than 100 yen per student). It could therefore be embedded into any microbiology course at very little cost. Furthermore, the assessment with Cronbach α scores and DIs verified the reliability of items in questionnaire on estimating the changes in awareness via practical, suggesting that it was a meaningful way to improve awareness of microbiology in particular unseen bacteria inhabiting around us among nursing students.
As expected, comparing the questionnaires showed that the practical improved awareness of unseen bacteria inhabiting around us among nursing students. Awareness was significantly increased of fomites (utensils and contact-based), habitats (body surface), actions facilitating hospital infection, and physical changes in condition caused by bacterial infections, but not in word associations or habitats (inside body). It is well-known that visualizing structures or materials can improve students’ awareness of specific lecture topics, enabling them to better understand lectures [17, 18]. It has, for example, been reported that the oral microbiology lab curriculum appears to improve the quality of oral medicine education and help to cultivate high-quality innovative medical talents . Experiential courses with an emphasis on patient-physician/dentist communication plays a significant role in early on during pre-clinical medical and dental studies . These studies therefore suggest that a combined lecture and practical approach could improve understanding of specific subjects. The observation of colonies may not be surprising, but being able to visualize previously-unseen life through the observations could enable the students to make a connection between those images and more familiar objects such as TV remote controls or stethoscopes. However, word associations and the inside of the body are harder to connect to the observed images, which may explain why the practical had no impact on the awareness of these areas among the nursing students. This may explain the necessity of advanced practical for acquiring deeper knowledge about infectious diseases to nursing students.
Altogether, we conclude that the simple and short practical in microbiology course offered to nursing students effectively improved their awareness of unseen bacteria inhabiting around us. Meanwhile, this practical has a limitation that this study provided only the second-grade nursing students class, lacking comparison to those of other nursing courses. Further study should be needed to clarify our conclusion.
Analysis of variance
Siegel JD, Rhinehart E, Jackson M, Chiarello L. The healthcare infection control practices advisory committee: Management of Multidrug-Resistant Organisms in Healthcare Settings. Atlanta: centers for disease control and. Prevention. 2006.
Samore MH, Venkataraman L, DeGirolami PC, Arbeit RD, Karchmer AW. Clinical and molecular epidemiology of sporadic and clustered cases of nosocomial Clostridium difficile diarrhea. Am J Med. 1996;100:32–40.
Hayden MK, Bonten MJ, Blom DW, Lyle EA, van de Vijver DA, Weinstein RA. Reduction in acquisition of vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus after enforcement of routine environmental cleaning measures. Clin Infect Dis. 2006;42:1552–60.
Hayden MK, Blom DW, Lyle EA, Moore CG, Weinstein RA. Risk of hand or glove contamination after contact with patients colonized with vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus or the colonized patient’s environment. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2008;29:149–54.
Martinez JA, Ruthazer R, Hansjosten K, Barefoot L, Snydman DR. Role of environmental contamination as a risk factor for acquisition of vancomycin-resistant enterococci by in patients treated in a medical intensive care unit. Arch Intern Med. 2003;163:1905–12.
Huang SS, Datta R, Platt R. Risk of acquiring antibiotic-resistant bacteria from prior room occupants. Arch Intern Med. 2006;166:1945–51.
Goodman ER, Platt R, Bass R, Onderdonk AB, Yokoe DS, Huang SS. Impact of an environmental cleaning intervention on the presence of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and vancomycin-resistant enterococci on surfaces in intensive care unit rooms. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2008;29:593–9.
Wu HM, Fornek M, Schwab KJ, Chapin AR, Gibson K, Schwab E. A norovirus outbreak at a long term–care facility: the role of environmental surface contamination. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2005;26:802–10.
Boyce JM. Environmental contamination makes an important contribution to hospital infection. J Hosp Infect. 2007;65(Suppl. 2):50–4.
Watanabe R, Shimoda T, Yano R, Hayashi Y, Nakamura S, Matsuo J, Yamaguchi H. Visualization of hospital cleanliness in three Japanese hospitals with a tendency toward long-term care. BMC Res Notes. 2014;7:121.
Gail C, Field KW, Simpson T, Bond EF. Clinical nurse specialists and nurse practitioners: complementary roles for infectious disease and infection control. Am J Infect Control. 2004;32(4):239–42.
Soledad M, Ramirez K. Influence of undergraduate nursing student teaching methods on learning standard precautions and transmission-based precautions: experimental research. Nurse Educ Today. 2018;61:101–5.
Japanese Nursing Association. URL: https://www.nurse.or.jp/jna/english/.
Kawashima A. Critical thinking integration into nursing education and practice in Japan: views on its reception from foreign-trained Japanese nursing educators. Contemp Nurse. 2003;15(3):199–208.
Yardley S, Teunissen PW, Dornan T. Experiential learning: AMEE Guide No. 63. Med Teach. 2012;34(2):e102–15.
Syed HA, ACa P, Kenneth GR. Validity and reliability of scores obtained on multiple-choice questions: why functioning distractors matter. Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning. 2016;16(1):14.
Jaswal SS, O'Hara PB, Williamson PL, Springer AL. Teaching structure: student use of software tools for understanding macromolecular structure in an undergraduate biochemistry course. Biochem Mol Biol Educ. 2013;41(5):351–9.
Haidegger T, Nagy M, Lehotsky A, Szilágyi L. Digital imaging for the education of proper surgical hand disinfection. Med Image Comput Comput Assist Interv. 2011;14(Pt 3):619–26.
Nie M, Gao ZY, Wu XY, Jiang CX, Du JH. Evaluation of oral microbiology lab curriculum reform. BMC Medical Education. 2015;15:217.
Alvarez S, Schultz JH. A communication-focused curriculum for dental students – an experiential training approach. BMC Medical Education. 2018;18:55.
We thank the staff members of the Departments of Medical Laboratory Science and Nursing, Faculty of Health Sciences, Hokkaido University, for their assistance throughout this study.
We thank Melissa Leffler, MBA, from Edanz Group (www.edanzediting.com/ac) for editing a draft of this manuscript.
This work was funded by operating support funds, Hokkaido University.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets generated and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Ethics approval was obtained from the Ethics Committee of the University of Hokkaido (reference number 17–75). The participant consent was verbal. We received ethics committee approval for verbal consent. All participants were informed of the purpose of the study. They were entirely voluntary and were assured that the data would be treated with confidentiality and anonymity.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.