- Research article
- Open Access
Internet or dvd for distance learning to isolated rural health professionals, what is the best approach?
BMC Medical Education volume 17, Article number: 152 (2017)
Distance Learning (DL) is a means to overcome the barriers that prevent health workers access to medical education and training sessions to update their knowledge. The main objective of this study is to compare the knowledge acquisition among practitioners Heads of Health Based Center (HBC) for the management of hypertension in two training modalities, one interactive, via internet (by Visio conferencing and video Conferencing), and other non-interactive, via DVD in the three regions (Miarinarivo, Moramanga and Manjakandriana) of Madagascar.
This is a quasi-experimental study comparing two distance learning methodologies, one via internet (VS or VD) and the other via DVD before and after training.
Ninety-two (92) Heads of HBC participated in the training, including 56 via the Internet (24 doctors and 32 paramedics) and 36 via DVD (24 doctors and 12 paramedics).
According to the training mode: the mean score of knowledge of the participants was 7 (+ −2) for two terms before training. It is 14 (+ −2.5) in the internet group (VS or VD) and 15 (+ −2.7) in the DVD group after training. The difference between the two groups was not significant p = 0.076. For doctors, the score was 7 (+ −3.1) via internet and 8 (+ −2.3) via DVD in pre test and 14 (+ − 2.4) via internet and 16 (+ −. 2.7) via DVD in post test, the difference between the two training methods was significant (p = 0.008). Among the paramedics, the results are the same for both conditions, 7 (+ − 2.4 to + −3.2) in pre test and 14 (+ − 2.2 to + −2.7) in post test.
Both training methods have improved participants’ knowledge and the DVD mode is the first choice for Heads HBC of Madagascar with the majority located in remote areas.
In medicine, progress is rapid, and it is becoming increasingly difficult for practitioners to remain well aware of the various practices regarding the management of patient medical care. Access to information is increasingly difficult for practitioners working in rural areas .
Traditionally, to ensure the transfer of knowledge, face-to-face training is preferred. However, due to problems related to access and cost, this is not always possible. Remote-delivery training (RDT) can mitigate these problems [2,3,4] by organizing training using the internet (online training, Visio conferencing (VS) and videoconferencing (VD)) or by correspondence (sending documents or digital support, such as DVDs). The main advantage of training using VS or VD is the visual contact and, in particular, the direct interaction between tutors and students (VS) or live chat (VD), which does not happen with training online or via correspondence. Training via correspondence allows a dispatch at a large scale into areas where internet access is impossible, and it offers learners greater flexibility to study the course according to their availability, including re-examining the course as much as they can, based on their needs. Training via DVD may allow a visual picture of the tutor.
In Madagascar, the management of patients’ medical care is mainly based in Health-based Centers (HBC), a first-recourse medical structure, for the majority of the population, particularly in rural areas. The function of the heads of HBC may be insured by a doctor or a paramedic (nurse or midwife). The knowledge level of these staff and their number of years in service vary according to the type of studies carried out. Consequently, there is no certainty that the latest recommendations established for the management of patient care are known and/or implemented. With the development of the internet in certain areas, and given the multiple difficulties regarding face-to-face training, it is urgent to identify the most effective remote-delivery training modalities to address these issues.
One in 4 persons over 35 years old ignores his/her arterial hypertension or is untreated . The prevalence of the HTA in Antananarivo was 28.05% in 2009 and 19.10% in 2000 . In Moramanga, it was estimated to be 27.6% in 2013 .
The number of international studies comparing the different remote-delivery training modalities is weak. None was carried out in a low-income country such as Madagascar. In the majority of studies (7/11), online training via the internet is the training modality used for the comparison, but this can be used only in locations where a permanent internet connection exists, which is not the case for the majority of health centers in Madagascar. Training using VS and VD is possible in Madagascar during the monthly regrouping of the heads of HBC in the health district office.
The goal of this study is an empirical research. The main objective was to identify the most effective remote-delivery training modalities for the training of rural doctors in Madagascar. The main objective was to compare the knowledge acquisition of the heads of HBC for the management of hypertension in two training modalities, one interactive, via internet (by Visio conferencing and video Conferencing), and other non-interactive, via DVD. The cost of each training modality and their acceptance by the practitioners was also evaluated.
This is an empirical quasi-experimental study comparing two remote-delivery training modalities, one via internet (VS and VD) and the other via DVD.
The participants were the heads of HBC (doctors or paramedics) based in the areas Miarinarivo, Moramanga and Manjakandriana. Each area was assigned a model of training to avoid intra-area contamination and the dissemination of training content among the heads of HBC (cf. Fig. 1).
A training session where all the heads of HBC were invited was organized in each area by the District Services of Public Health (DSPH) of the High Plateaus, located at the center of the island. The training by Visio conferencing was organized live during the training session and held at the Medical Institute of Madagascar (telemedicine site of the Pan African e-network Project in Antananarivo), and the training via videoconferencing was held at the laboratory of Support to Research and Technologies Information and Communication of the Faculty of Medicine of Antananarivo. The training via VS or VD was projected on a large screen. The interaction was live with the course tutor for the VS and indirect via chat for VD. The duration of the training (including the evaluations) was two hours. The DVDs were distributed to the participants during the regrouping of the heads of the HBC. The training course was held at a doctor’s home without tutor contact.
The printed slides were distributed to the participants of the two training modalities. The training was in French, and the discussion was in Malagasy or French, according to the wishes of the participants. The contents of the training related to the synthesis of the recommendations issued by the European Society of Hypertension (ESH), the European Society of Cardiology (ESC),  and the French Society of Cardiology (SFC),  for the management of the medical care of patients with arterial hypertension. A knowledge-assessment questionnaire on the management of hypertension was developed based on questionnaires published in the literature [10,11,12]. The contextualization of the questionnaire was based on “Toolkit on Translating and Adapting Instruments” developed by Ligia M. Chávez. It contained 20 items, including 4 on the diagnosis, 9 on the treatment, 2 on the hygiene dietetics measure (MHD) and 5 on the follow up and the complications of hypertension. Questions were asked in the form of questions with multiple choices (QCM). It was tested on ten doctors who were not included in the study.
At the beginning of the first training course and then 1 month after the training, during the new meeting of the heads of HBC, the participants filled out the questionnaire individually.
Evaluation of training modalities
Two tools were used to measure the rate of satisfaction:
An individual questionnaire containing 10 items consists to know the participant’s satisfaction degree of the training modality: 3 on the appreciation of the methods and the quality of the contents of the course, 2 on the quality of the images and sound, 1 on the duration of training, 1 on the language of teaching (French or Malagasy) and 1 indicating agreement or disagreement to pay the expenses of training. The rate of satisfaction was noted on a scale from 1 to 3 (1: very satisfactory, 2: satisfying and 3: not satisfactory).
A focus group by site. Each group was composed of 8 heads of HBC (4 doctors and 4 paramedics for Visio conferencing, 5 doctors and 3 paramedics for videoconferencing, and 6 doctors and 2 paramedics for training via DVD). Participants were included if they had at least 5 years of service as a head of HBC, were locatedless than 50 km from a road accessible to the health district year round, and agreed to take part in the focus group. An interview guideline was developed. It comprised 2 items on general appreciation, 1 on the proceeding of the training, 3 on its contents, 3 on the document distributed and 2 on possible suggestions to improve the contents and training modality.
Costs of the evaluation
The cost of each training modality was divided into expenditures related to the investment in IT equipment and expenditures linked to the operation costs. The capital expenditures were supported by the Medical Institute of Madagascar for the VS and by the Research Laboratory in Technology Information and Communication for the VD and the recording of the DVD. The operating expenses comprised common expenditures (tutors’ fees, the knowledge-assessment questionnaire, and training support (printing of the slides) and specific expenditures for each type of training modality (cost of internet connection and manufacturing costs of the DVDs).
The qualitative data were described as numbers and percentages, and the quantitative data were described as the mean (standard deviation) or median (quartiles), according to whether their distribution was Gaussian.
The questions about knowledge were gathered in 3 categories (cf. Table 1):
7 questions concerning the essential measures to take in the event of simple hypertension
6 questions about management of resistant or complicated hypertension
7 questions about non-essential but useful general knowledge for a good management of hypertension
Each item was coded 1 for a correct answer and 0 for an incorrect answer. Participants’ average score was calculated by dividing the total marks obtained by all participants for each training modality by the total number of participants. The comparison of the scores for the knowledge before and after the training course was carried out by a paired t-test for each training modality.
The comparison of scores for knowledge between the two training modalities and between the professional groups (doctors versus paramedics) was performed by Student’s t-test.
The comparison of participants’ satisfaction with each training modality was performed by a chi-squared test. The significance was fixed at p < 0.05. These analyses were performed with SPSS18 software.
Characteristics of the participants (cf. Table 2)
Among the 101 heads of HBC working in 3 SDSP, 92 (91%) took part in the training; 48 (52%) were doctors, and 44 (48%) were nurses. The distribution of the participants in terms of number and professional group were unequal between the two training modalities.
The median age of the heads of CSB was 45 years (minimum 24, maximum 58 years). The internet group was younger (42 years) than the DVD group (46 years) (p < 0.05). The paramedics in the DVD group were on average older (48 years) than all the other participants.
The median duration of the paramedics’ service was higher than that of the doctors’ (20 versus 16) (p < 0.05).
The evolution of the knowledge of the heads of HBC according to the training modalities (internet versus DVD) per professional group and per hypertension characteristics (Table 3)
By training modality
Before the training, regardless of the training modality, the mean score of knowledge obtained by all participants was 7 ± 2. After training, the score was 14 ± 2.5 in the internet group (i.e., by VS or VD) and 15 ± −2.7 in the DVD group (see Table 3). There was no difference between the gain in the internet and DVD groups (p = 0.076).
In the internet group, the average score after the training for the doctors and the paramedics was the same 14.
The average knowledge gain of the doctors using the internet was 7 and of those using DVDs was 8.The difference between the two training modalities was significant (p = 0.008).
For paramedics, the average gain was identical to +7 in the two groups (p = 0.364).
By hypertension characteristics: Simple hypertension, resistant and complicated hypertension and useful knowledge for the management of hypertension
The average gain of knowledge of the item management of simple HTA was identical for the two training modalities (+1). On the other hand, for the 6 items on resistant or complicated hypertension and the 7 items on useful knowledge for HTA, the average gains were even, 4 in the DVD group and 3 in the internet group. The difference between the two modalities was significant (p < 0.025).
Participants’ acceptance of the two training modalities
The overall rate of participants’ appreciation was the same for the two training modalities (89%). It was the same for the contents of course (85% internet, 84% DVD), for the images and sound (79% internet, DVD 80%) and for the duration of the training (68% internet, 71% DVD). Slightly one third fewer (29%) training participants using the internet would agree to pay course fees, compared to 16% of those in training using DVD.
All participants in the focus group found the training sessions interesting and appreciated that they were run efficiently. Twenty four Head of HBC have participated in the focus group, 15 doctors and 9 paramedics (4 doctors and 4 paramedics for the visioconference, 5 doctors et 3 paramedics for the videoconference, 6 doctors et 2 paramedics for the DVD). Those internet training found that the duration was short and that they could not ask questions. Those in the DVD training found that the explanations were fast, and the disadvantage was that it was not possible to ask questions and request clarifications. The advantage for the DVD training was that it is possible to re-watch the course if necessary.
Despite these inconveniences, all participants (DVD and internet groups) found that the information was very clear.
The common costs of the two training modalities were 0.86 euro per participant. This included the tutor fees (0.33 euros), the duplication of the knowledge-assessment questionnaires (0,21euros) and the duplication of the training resources (0.32 euros). The cost of a 60-min internet connection was 18 euros for VS and 8 euros for VD. The production of DVD was 18 euros. Overall, the cost per participant was 4 euros for the training via VS and 3 euros for the training via VD or via DVD, meaning that for 92 rural HBC in 3 SDSP, the expenditure was 368 euros for the training via VS and 276 euros for the training via VD or DVD.
Following this empirical study, we can conclude that the two training modalities, via the internet and via DVD, had the same effectiveness in terms of knowledge improvement on the management of hypertension. The two methods of distance training continuing medical education allowed the update of the knowledge for the health professional in remote areas and are acceptable by healths professionals.
In both cases, the level of knowledge doubled after the training, but it did not reach 100%. The gain of the training via DVD was slightly higher (+1) than the gain of the training via the internet. There was no difference between the average scores for the knowledge acquisition of the characteristics for simple hypertension and resistant or complicated hypertension, according to the training modalities. The majority of the participants appreciated the two training modalities. They thought that both could be used as remote-delivery training to provide continuous medical training.
The training cost of using VD or DVD was 3 euros per participant, one euro less than using VS. Training via VD or DVD was less expensive than training via VS, but the advantage of VS is that it offers direct interaction with the tutor. To enable the heads of all 2504 Madagascar HBC to access the remote-delivery training, the cost of training via VD and DVD would be obviously lower than training via VS (7512 euros vs. 10.016 euros).
The limitation of this study is the absence of the randomization of the leaders of HBC.
The bias here is limited because the basic knowledge (before training) in both groups was the same (the overall score but not per group). The generalization of the data to all Malagasy rural area physicians is not possible.
This study is the first study to compare training via the internet and training via DVD.
The effectiveness of the training of health professionals via the internet or correspondence has been evaluated for approximately ten years, with a recrudescence in the number studies in the past five years. The effectiveness has mainly been measured with two indicators, knowledge acquisition gain (mean score or percentage) and satisfaction with the teaching.
Five non-comparative studies were carried out mainly in countries with low income.The topics varied widely, i.e., palliative care , AIDS , management of hypercholesterolemia , management of hepatitis C viral , support of advanced-life patients , research on epidemiology and biostatistics,  prevention of falls , medical ethics , and cancer . Five 5 non-comparative studies were conducted. Two evaluated training on digital support (CD-ROM: Doctors in Tunisia  and France ), and 3 evaluated training via internet (2 videoconferences: doctors in Iraq , Cambodia  and 1 video conference: health workers from 12 African countries . The first two studies aimed for a threefold and fivefold gain of knowledge and the satisfaction of the participants on the content as well as the audio-visual presentation. In the other 3, despite the absence of an objective measurement of the knowledge gain, the participants were satisfied with the content and methodologies used.
All comparative studies were carried out in countries with a high income USA [15, 16, 21, 27, 28], Spain , Australia , Japan , Iran [14, 18], India , and none were conducted in countries with a low income.
Among these 11 studies, 9 compared face-to-face training via internet training, online internet (5), via VS (2) and via VD (2) and 2 compared online training to training via correspondence, sending documents (1) or DVD (1). The comparison concerned mainly (7) online training.
The results of these 11 studies aimed for a double increase or more in the gain of knowledge and did not reach 100% after the training, whether via the internet or via correspondence. The gain of knowledge via the internet was equal to (28 vs. 30, 81 vs. 90, 15 vs. 13, 5 vs. 3, 2 vs. 4, 4 vs. 4) or greater than (5vs.2, 59 vs. 43, 22 vs. 16, 12 vs. 5) face-to-face training. The gain of knowledge was greater for training via DVD than online training (7 vs. 5).
Patients’ satisfaction of was assessed in only 7 of the 11 studies (4 online/face to face, 1 VD/face to face and 2 online/documents and DVDs). In all these studies, the rate was high (85%), regardless of the modality used. The satisfaction rate of the heads of HBC regarding the contents (80%) rejoined with the two studies [15, 21].
The lesson learned mainly from this study is that DVD’s are as good as internet distance learning method for this kind of knowledge acquisition. By taking into account the cost of training and the absence of an internet connection in the majority of the HBC based in rural and remote areas, the training by DVD is the first choice for continuous medical training for heads of HBC. In fact, the majority of them have DVD players. Taking account of the trend of the increasing internet coverage in Madagascar, the VD would be the second viable option.
Two questions are left unanswered. Regardless of the remote-delivery training modality, the acquisition of knowledge did not reach 100%. The items least known by the participants after the training were the characteristics of simple hypertension and resistant or complicated hypertension relating to medical treatment and the follow up.
The second question concerns the relationship between knowledge acquired during the training and general practice whilst seeing a patient.
These two questions will be treated later on.
It can be deduced that the three training modalities made it possible to improve participants' knowledge of the management of hypertension. The average Scores of knowledge acquisition of participant and participant satisfaction were the same for the 3 training modalities. From a cost perspective, VD and DVD were cheaper than VS the following recommendations are recommended:
If the DSPH has an Internet connection cover, the choice should be made between VD and DVD.
If the coverage in Internet connection is weak or does not exist at the level of the DSPH, the mode by DVD is the only realizable.
European Society of Cardiology
European Society of Hypertension
Hygiene dietetics measure
Questions with multiple choices
French Society of Cardiology
Veldenzh S, Dennis JW. The internet and education in surgery. American Surgery 1998; 64(9): 877.
Langilled B, Allen MJ, Sargeant JM. Assessment of the acceptability and costs of interactive videoconferencing for continuing medical education in Nova Scotia. Journal of Continuing Education for the Health professionals 1998; 18: 11–19.
Dillon CL. Distance education research and continuing professional education: reframing questions for the emerging information infrastructure. Journal of Continuing Education for the Health professionals1996. 16:5–13.
Henri F, Kaye A. Le savoir à domicile, Québec. Presses de l’Université du Québec et Télé-université1985; 5–28.
S Le Jeune, JJ Mourad. Revues Générales Hypertension artérielle: Inobservance et inertie clinique: deux obstacles majeurs à la prise en charge de l’hypertension artérielle. Service de Médecine Interne et Hypertension Artérielle, Hôpital Avicenne, Bobigny. Réalités Cardiologiques, 2012; 286.
H Rabarijaona, P Rakotomalala, J Rakotonirina et al. Prévalence et sévérité de l’hypertension artérielle de l’adulte en milieu urbain à Antananarivo. Revue d’Anesthésie-Réanimation et de Médecine d’Urgence, 2009(Septembre-Octobre); 1(4): 24–27.
R Ratovoson, O Rasetarinera Rabariso, C Rogier et al. L’hypertension artérielle chez les adultes en milieu rural à Moramanga, Madagascar. Revue d'Épidémiologie et de Santé Publique, 2014 Septembre; 62(5):S229.
ESC/ESH. Les recommandations’ européennes 2013 sur l'HTA … (ESH) et l'European Society of Cardiology (ESC) Vienne … congrès de l'ESHwww.realites-cardiologiques.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/.../Recommandations.pdf. Accessed 22 Dec 2014.
Nouvelles recommandations de la Société Française de Cardiologie SFC. Bruno Pavy; 24 janvier 2013. www.realites-cardiologiques.com/wp-content/uploads/2013. Accessed 22 Dec 2014
QCM d'autoévaluation sur l'HTA (amem.free.fr/textes/autoeval.htm).
Cardiologie-QCM + Corrigé type cours de médecine. (Free-h.net/qcms.../cardiologie qcm-corrige-type)Conf_HTA_-_QCM_et_dossiers_corriges.pdf (www.saipr.fr/blog/). http://www.tresordemedecine.com/qcms-dossiers-preparation-residanat/qcm-cardio-corrige-type-t128.html.
Hypertension Artérielle Essentielle 1 www-sante.ujf-grenoble.fr/SANTE/corpus/disciplines/…/hta/…/qcm.h.
Pelayo M, Cebrián D, Areosa A, et al. Effects of online palliative care training on knowledge, attitude and satisfaction of primary care physicians. BMC Fam Pract. 2011;12:37.
Khatony A, Nayery ND, Ahmadi F, et al. The effectiveness of web-based and face-to-face continuing education methods on nurses' knowledge about AIDS: a comparative study. BMC Medical Education. 2009;9:41.
Michael Fordis, Jason E. King, Christie M. Ballantyne et al (G3SA). Comparison of the Instructional Efficacy of Internet-Based CME with Live Interactive CME Workshops: A Randomized Controlled Trial. JAMA. 2005;294:9.jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/201477. Accessed19 Aug 2014.
Rossaro L, Tran TP, Ransibrahmanakul K, et al. Hepatitis C videoconferencing: the impact on continuing medical education for rural healthcare providers. Telemedicine Journal and e- Health. 2007 Jun;13(3):269–77.
Horiuchi S, Yaju Y, Koyo M, et al. Evaluation of a web based graduate continuing nursing education program in Japan: a randomized controlled trial. Elsevier, Nurse Educ Today. 2009;29:140–9. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18829141. Accessed 18 Aug 2014.
Aggarwal R, Gupte N, Kass N, et al. A comparison of online versus on-site training in Health Research methodology: a randomized study. BMC medical education. 2011;11:37. https://bmcmededuc.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1472-6920-11-37. Accessed 19 Dec 2014.
Maloney S, Haas R, Keating JL, et al. Effectiveness of web-based versus face-to-face delivery of education in prescription of falls-prevention exercise to health professionals: randomized trial. J Med Internet Res. 2011;13(4):e116.
Dodani S, Kazmi KA, Laporte RE, et al. Effectiveness of research training workshop taught by traditional and video-teleconference methods in a developing country. Global public health. 2010;5(1):113.
Blaze KR, Christie C, Uman G, et al. Impact of web-based case conferencing on cancer genetics training outcomes for community-based clinicians. J Cancer Educ. 2012, June;27(2)
Ben Salah N, El Borgi W, Aounallah Skhiri H et al. Medical knowledge in immunological security of red blood cells transfusion in Tunisia: evaluation of a CD-ROM of auto-learning. Transfusion Clinique et Biologique: Journal de la société française de transfusion sanguine. 2013 Septembre; 20(4):448–453.
Pavese P, Coulouma M, Sellier E, et al. CDROM continuous medical education model for the management of urinary tract infections in family practice. Medicine et Maladies Infectieuses. 2012 Jul;42(7):321–6.
Donaldson RI, Mulligan DA, Nugent K, et al. Using tele-education to train civilian Physicians in area of active conflict. The journals of pediatrics. 2011;159(3). http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022347611004598. Accessed 22 Dec 2014.
Engle X, Aird J, Tho L. Combining continuing education with expert consultation via telemedicine in Cambodia. Trop Dr. 2014 April;44(2):62–8.
Reid MJ, Flam R, Tsiouris F, et al. New models for medical education: Web based conferencing to support HIV training in sub-Saharan Africa. Telemedicine Journal and e- Health. 2012 Sep;18(7):565–9.
Weeksa DL, et al. Pediatric advanced life support re-training by videoconferencing compared to face-to-face instruction: a planned non-inferiority trial. Resuscitation. 2008;79:109–17. http://www.sciencedirect.com Accessed 18 Aug 2014
Halley MC, Rendle KA, Gillespie KA et al. An exploratory mixed-methods crossover study comparing DVD- vs. web-based patient decision support in three conditions: the importance of patient perspectives. Health Expectations 2014,Wiley online library accessed 22 Déc 2014.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Authorization N° 024- MSANP/CE delivered on 30 march 2012 from the Ethics Committee of the Ministry of Health and consent to participate were obtained.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Rakototiana, L.B., Rajabo & Gottot, S. Internet or dvd for distance learning to isolated rural health professionals, what is the best approach?. BMC Med Educ 17, 152 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-017-0991-3
- Distance learning
- Training method
- Knowledge acquisition
- Health professional