Table 3 Post-examination feedback from trainees in three groups (n = 147)
SSP-TCM group (n, %) | OSP-TCM group (n, %) | TM group (n, %) | P-value(χ2)a | P-value(χ2)b | P-value(χ2)c | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Your test performance achieves what fidelity rate of your usual performance? | >99% 19(38.78) | 71–99% 15(30.61) | 40–70% 12(24.49) | <40% 3(6.12) | >99% 17(34.69) | 71–99% 19(38.78) | 40–70% 11(22.45) | <40% 2(4.08) | >99% 6(12.24) | 71–99% 20(40.82) | 40–70% 19(38.78) | <40% 4(8.16) | 0.027(9.198) | 0.044(8.087) | 0.843(0.825) |
Do you think the “patient” in examination act like a real patient? | Yes, very likely 6(12.24) | Acceptable 16(32.65) | No, unlikely 19(38.78) | No opinion 8(16.33) | Yes, very likely 7(14.29) | Acceptable 15(30.61) | No, unlikely 15 (30.61) | No opinion 12(24.49) | Yes, very likely 18(36.73) | Acceptable 15 (30.61) | No, unlikely 11(22.45) | No opinion 5(10.20) | 0.031(8.858) | 0.040(8.338) | 0.710(1.380) |
Do you think the scenario preparation is authentic in examination? | Yes, very much 10(20.41) | Yes, but slightly 17(34.69) | Not at all 17(34.69) | No opinion 5(10.20) | Yes, very much 13(26.53) | Yes, but slightly 17(34.69) | Not at all 17(34.69) | No opinion 2(4.08) | Yes, very much 21(42.86) | Yes, but slightly 14(28.57) | Not at all 7(14.29) | No opinion 7(14.29) | 0.034(8.694) | 0.028(9.117) | 0.642(1.677) |
The time length for the patient encounter in examination is? | Adequate 25(51.02) | Too long 3(6.12) | Too short 13 (26.53) | No opinion 8(16.33) | Adequate 23(46.94) | Too long 0(0.00) | Too short 21(42.86) | No opinion 5(10.20) | Adequate 16(32.65) | Too long 0(0.00) | Too short 19(38.78) | No opinion 14(28.57) | 0.052(7.737) | 0.060(5.620) | 0.129(5.658) |
Dose the video recording in examination interferes with your performance? | Yes, very much 9(18.37) | Yes, but slightly 19(38.78) | Not at all 16(32.65) | No opinion 5(10.20) | Yes, very much 12(24.49) | Yes, but slightly 14(28.57) | Not at all 17(34.69) | No opinion 6(12.24) | Yes, very much 21(42.86) | Yes, but slightly 18(36.73) | Not at all 6(12.24) | No opinion 4(8.16) | 0.024(9.484) | 0.035(8.615) | 0.727(1.307) |