Table 3 ISS to assess and promote system readiness and safety cultures
From: GENESISS 2—Generating Standards for In-Situ Simulation project: a systematic mapping review
Author, date (Country) | Research topic | Setting and participants | Outcome methods and measures | Study type (JBI level of evidence) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Abulebda 2018 [70] (US) | Assessing paediatric readiness and adherence to guidelines | ED (10 ED departments), MDT teams (n = 41) | 1. Paediatric Readiness Score | Prospective observational Quality assessment – moderate (3e) |
Bender 2011 [13] (US) | Improve system readiness and staff preparedness in a new NICU | Neonatal ICU (n = 148) | 1. System readiness TESTPILOT 2. Identification of LSTs 3. Staff preparedness | Prospective observational Quality assessment: moderate (3e) |
Gardner 2013 [71] (Canada) | ED preparedness: LST detection, orientation, preparedness | ED (n = 55) | 1, System readiness 2. Workplace satisfaction | Prospective observational Quality assessment—good (3e) |
Hinde 2016 [74] (UK) | Improve safety culture of operating theatres | OR (n = 72) | 1. Safety attitude questionnaire 2. Safety Climate scores 3. Teamwork scores | Prospective observational Quality assessment – moderate (3e) |
Jaffry 2019 [75] (UK) | Enhance compliance with safety checklists and promote the safety culture | (n = 25) | 1. Knowledge and confidence scores 2. Compliance with the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist | Prospective observational Quality assessment: moderate (3e) |
Kobayashi 2006 [72] (US) | Evaluate the capacity of a new ED for emergent resuscitative processes and assist facility orientation | ED (n = 14) | 1. Staff preparedness 2. Orientation scores | Prospective observational Quality assessment – moderate (3e) |
Paltved 2017 [73] (Denmark) | Enhance patient safety attitudes | (n = 39) | 1. Safety attitude questionnaires 2. Safety climate scores 3. Teamwork scores | Prospective observational Quality assessment: good (3e) |
Patterson 2013 [69] (US) | To decrease the frequency and mitigate the effects of medical error | Paediatric ED (n = 289 / n = 151) | 1. Safety climate scores 2. Teamwork climate scores | Prospective observational Quality assessment: good (3e) |
Ventre 2014 [76] (US) | Evaluate operational readiness | Children’s hospital obstetric unit (n = 133) | 1. LST detection rate 2. Equipment checklists | Prospective observational Quality assessment: moderate—good (3e) |