Skip to main content

Table 1 Mean ratings by domain and assessor

From: Exploring assessor cognition as a source of score variability in a performance assessment of practice-based competencies

 Assessor 1Assessor 2Assessor 3Assessor 4Assessor 5Assessor 6Assessor 7
d15.14 (1.66)5.14 (0.53)5.50 (1.29)5.23 (0.72)5.82 (1.25)5.23 (0.93)5.36 (0.80)
d25.29 (1.44)4.86 (1.23)4.92 (1.71)4.75 (1.22)5.00 (0.77)4.92 (0.95)5.32 (1.14)
d35.29 (1.54)5.14 (0.95)5.36 (1.34)5.46 (0.97)5.80 (1.03)4.67 (0.89)4.82 (0.98)
d45.36 (1.39)4.86 (0.95)5.86 (0.95)5.38 (1.04)5.91 (1.30)4.54 (0.88)5.36 (0.81)
d55.29 (1.33)5.07 (1.49)5.71 (0.99)5.46 (0.97)5.00 (1.00)4.62 (0.87)5.00 (0.77)
d65.07 (1.82)4.43 (1.60)5.57 (0.85)5.31 (0.85)5.09 (0.94)5.00 (1.34)4.65 (1.11)
Holistic8.31 (0.96)7.89 (0.63)8.89 (1.05)7.96 (0.44)7.64 (0.34)8.12 (0.75)7.96 (0.49)
 Assessor 8Assessor 9Assessor 10Assessor 11Assessor 12Assessor 13Assessor 14
d16.43 (0.76)5.93 (1.32)5.62 (0.87)5.92 (1.04)5.92 (1.04)5.73 (0.90)5.62 (1.04)
d26.08 (1.03)6.14 (1.16)5.38 (0.65)4.92 (1.55)5.92 (1.32)5.91 (0.70)5.08 (1.04)
d36.07 (0.99)5.00 (1.46)5.33 (0.65)4.46 (1.05)5.60 (0.97)5.82 (0.87)4.69 (1.18)
d46.00 (0.85)5.14 (1.79)5.62 (0.87)4.92 (0.86)5.62 (1.26)5.82 (0.75)4.15 (0.99)
d55.43 (1.01)5.57 (1.45)5.46 (0.78)5.15 (1.21)5.54 (1.39)4.73 (0.65)4.46 (0.88)
d65.54 (1.05)4.92 (1.82)5.17 (0.39)4.46 (1.61)4.83 (1.53)5.27 (0.90)4.77 (1.09)
Holistic8.36 (0.93)8.75 (1.07)8.15 (0.47)7.82 (0.71)8.12 (0.85)7.95 (0.39)8.04 (0.85)
  1. The score of each domain ranges from 1 to 7; the holistic score ranges from 1 to 10. Standard deviations are presented in parentheses
  2. Note: d = domain; d1 = professionalism; d2 = communication; d3 = theory, models and/or frame of reference; d4 = knowledge of client; d5 = clinical reasoning; d6 = evidence-based practice