Skip to main content

Table 2 Results from the Virtual patient design and curricular integration evaluation toolkit developed by Huwendiek and de Leng

From: Virtual patients versus small-group teaching in the training of oral and maxillofacial surgery: a randomized controlled trial

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

Mean

SD

Authenticity of patient encounter and the consultation

While working on this case, I felt I had to make the same decisions a doctor would make in real life.

3

8

8

10

0

0

3.12

1.17

While working on this case, I felt I were the doctor caring for this patient.

1

11

13

8

0

0

2.85

0.82

Professional approach in the consultation

While working through this case, I was actively engaged in gathering the information (e.g., history questions, physical exams, lab tests) I needed, to characterize the patient’s problem.

4

6

10

10

3

0

3.06

1.15

While working through this case, I was actively engaged in revising my initial image of the patient’s problem as new information became available.

2

4

10

11

5

1

3.48

1.16

While working through this case, I was actively engaged in creating a short summary of the patient’s problem using medical terms.

6

3

7

8

9

0

3.33

1.43

While working through this case, I was actively engaged in thinking about which findings supported or refuted each diagnosis in my differential diagnosis.

1

3

10

13

5

1

3.64

1.04

Coaching during consultation

I felt that the case was at the appropriate level of difficulty for my level of training.

0

5

9

14

5

0

3.58

0.92

The questions I was asked while working through this case were helpful in enhancing my diagnostic reasoning in this case.

0

1

3

19

10

0

4.15

0.70

The feedback I received was helpful in enhancing my diagnostic reasoning in this case.

0

1

3

17

12

0

4.21

0.73

Learning effect of consultation

After completing this case, I feel better prepared to confirm a diagnosis and exclude differential diagnoses in a real life patient with this complaint.

0

0

6

12

15

0

4.27

0.75

After completing this case I feel better prepared to care for a real life patient with this complaint.

0

1

8

15

8

1

4.00

0.85

Overall judgment of case workup

Overall, working through this case was a worthwhile learning experience.

0

0

2

10

21

0

4.58

0.6

Special strengths of the case:

Video footage illustrated investigation very closely; Individual speed; Well structured, detaileled; interesting cases; multimedia presentation, Clear structure; real pictures; Detailed explanation of the basics;

multiple editing possible, understandable, supported with images;

good portioning of content in “learning packages”

Special weaknesses of the case:

In the answers, the individual feedback should be shown directly; Staging and CT findings overstraining; processing time too short

  1. Significant results were marked in boldface