Skip to main content

Table 4 Kappa coefficient among task-specific checklist, holistic rubric, and analytic rubrics scores in the OSCE and CPX

From: Holistic rubric vs. analytic rubric for measuring clinical performance levels in medical students

 

Holistic rubric

Analytic rubrics

Task-specific checklist

OSCE (n = 488)

 Holistic rubric

–

0.512*

0.441*

 Analytic rubrics

0.512*

–

0.429*

 Task-specific checklist

0.441*

0.429*

–

CPX (n = 291)

 Holistic rubric

–

0.255*

0.351*

 Analytic rubrics

0.255*

–

0.420*

 Task-specific checklist

0.351*

0.420*

–

  1. *P < 0.001, OSCE; objective structured clinical examination, CPX; clinical performance examination. Students who were less than 1SD from the average were regarded as having failed the assessment. Then, the pass/fail agreement between the three evaluations was examined using the Kappa coefficient
Back to article page

BMC Medical Education

ISSN: 1472-6920

Contact us