Table 3 Holistic rubric for assessing an applicant profile
From: New non-cognitive procedures for medical applicant selection: a qualitative analysis in one school
Dimension | % of evidence in category | |
Criteria | ||
* A profile containing >14.29% evidence in any category will have 1 point (in the 5 point scale rubric). If the category is negative it will have a minus 1 point. | ||
* A profile containing between 10% - 14.28% evidence in any category will have partial points according to the following description: | ||
% Evidence in Category | Scale Points | |
14.00 – 14.49 | .9 | |
13.5 – 13.99 | .8 | |
13.00 – 13.49 | .7 | |
12.5 – 12.99 | .6 | |
12.00 – 12.49 | .5 | |
11.5 – 11.99 | .4 | |
11.00 – 11.49 | .3 | |
10.5 – 10.99 | .2 | |
10.00 – 10.49 | .1 | |
Benchmarks: | A profile will score 1 if it contains >14.29% evidence in any category or has accumulated partial points according to the description on the table above. | |
A profile will score 2 if it contains >14.29% evidence in 2 categories or has accumulated partial points according to the description on the table above. | ||
A profile will score 3 if it contains >14.29% evidence in 3 categories or has accumulated partial points according to the description on the table above. | ||
A profile will score 4 if it contains >14.29% evidence in 4 categories or has accumulated partial points according to the description on the table above. | ||
A profile will score 5 if it contains >14.29% evidence in 5 categories or has accumulated partial points according to the description on the table above. | ||