Effective coping strategies utilised by medical students for mental health disorders during undergraduate medical education-a scoping review

Background Coping denotes cognitive, emotional and behavioural struggles to tackle a troubled person-environment association. Therefore, coping strategies (CSs) are vital for mental well-being. Widespread research studies have explored this domain, targeting caregivers, nurses, physicians and medical teachers, but limited research has been done to explore the common CSs utilised by medical students at the undergraduate medical education level. Therefore, we aimed to identify the frequently occurring CSs and their effects on mental health disorders (MHDs) through the evidence available in the existing literature. Methods For this scoping review, we searched the available literature (articles published from January 1, 1986, to March 31, 2021) on CSs at Google Scholar, PubMed and Scopus using the terms coping, medical students and undergraduate medical education. We included in our search all peer-reviewed journal articles whose central topics were the CSs employed by undergraduate medical students of any age, nationality, race and gender. Results From among the 2,134 articles that were found, 24 were ultimately included in the study. The articles were authored in 14 countries, allowing us to gather broader data to answer our research question. The first identified theme (MHDs) had four subthemes: stress (55% of the articles), depression (30%), anxiety (25%) and burnout (15%). The second theme (CSs), on the other hand, had eight subthemes: support seeking (60%), active coping (40%), acceptance (40%), avoidance/denial (40%), substance abuse (35%), faith/religion (25%), sports (25%) and miscellaneous (40%). Conclusions Themes and subthemes were identified about the most common CSs utilised by undergraduate medical students to tackle common MHDs in the context of medical education. Among the most used CSs was support (social and emotional) seeking. Teaching medical students how to cope with challenging times is essential. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12909-022-03185-1.

(CSs) for tackling stress and depression are of great importance [3] because the students' ability to meet the medical-school requirements and to handle challenging situations can affect their academic grades and health [4]. These strategies are behavioural and psychological ways of managing or lessening stressful events [5]. Moreover, S Folkman [6] defines coping as 'the constant cognitive change and behavioural adaptation when handling specific external and internal demands that are evaluated as something that exceeds the person's resources. Coping is an active process comprising a sequence of mutual responses through which the person and the situation intermingle and affect each other. It comprises a series of deliberate cognitive and behavioural actions taken to deal with the negative influence of a tense and traumatic situation. Individuals embrace a wide range of cognitive, emotional and behavioural processes while reacting to inner and outer burdens believed to be surpassing their typical assets [6].
Despite the efforts of medical institutes to create a favourable academic culture that would allow medical students to become highly able professionals, high-stress rates still occur in such institutes [7][8][9][10], which may have critical consequences on the students' future professional behaviour [11]. According to Schiller et al. [4], healthcare competence refers to an individual's modelling of a set of attitudes and values suitable for future healthcare providers. Healthcare authorities thus have the indispensable role of helping 'students in need' cope with all the stressors they are bound to encounter in medical school, which may cause them to go on a downhill path academically and in terms of their health. This degradation may jeopardise the students' mental health during the undergraduate medical years, with lasting and devastating consequences or implications in the years to come (i.e. the clinical years).
Coping in various ways (problem resolving, positive judgement and expression of feelings) tends to be used by students to confront adverse circumstances. Positive reframing, planning and self-distraction are commonly used CSs [12,13], along with seeking support from peers and seniors, engaging in extracurricular activities, and resorting to religion and humour. These enable students to adapt to adverse circumstances relatively better [14], decrease their anxiety and depression and promote their mental well-being [15].
In recent times, literature discovered numerous MHDs, occurring commonly among healthcare stakeholders. There still lacks a robust exploration of practical CSs utilised by medical students at the undergraduate medical education level. This situation calls for a scoping review with specific objectives identifying practical CSs, utilised globally by undergraduate medical students to target MHDs. This shall have the potential ability to guide those in need. We hope, through this scoping review, once the effective CSs are listed, with evidence from the literature, the students might get help for their mental wellbeing and shall be able to avoid using harmful CSs which, instead of helping, might augment their problems. Therefore, this scoping review aimed to identify the frequently occurring CSs and their effectiveness on MHDs through the evidence available in the existing literature.

Methods
We aimed to use a scoping review approach that offers theoretical precision about a particular topic or area of literature by synthesising and analysing a broader array of literature [16]. Thus, we used H Arksey and L O'Malley [17] methodological framework, which has five stages: (1) identifying the research question; (2) identifying relevant studies; (3) selecting studies; (4) charting the data and (5) collating, summarising and reporting the results.

Stage 1: Identifying the research question
As mentioned earlier, this study aimed to discover the practical CSs used by undergraduate medical students. Our research question was 'What are the CSs that undergraduate medical students commonly use?' A functional definition of coping strategy was formulated for the study: patterns used by medical students to control their emotions, feelings and behaviours as they go through different periods of stress.

Stage 2: Identifying relevant studies
An electronic search for articles published within the period from January 1, 1986, to March 31, 2021, was done on Google Scholar (Google Inc., Mountain View, CA), PubMed (US National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD) and Scopus (Elsevier B.V., Amsterdam, Netherlands) databases. After repeated initial searches using various search engines, we found many articles published within the period mentioned above. A three-step search was employed. Firstly, we conducted a primary search on the Google Scholar, Pub-Med and Scopus databases in April 2021. We evaluated the article titles and abstracts that were found using the index terms employed. Secondly, we searched for fulltext articles on all the databases, employing the established keywords and index terms. Thirdly, we investigated the reference lists of all the examined studies to look for further studies. So as not to miss any pertinent research, we applied generally well-defined heading terms in the search, and we conducted the electronic search with the help of a librarian. Finally, we conducted various test searches to refine and improve the search terms. Articles were searched using Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) terms, and PubMed was considered the main source for building a search string that was also to be used for the other databases. Appropriate filters were applied to help retrieve articles based on specific characteristics and specific MeSH terms, publication types or dates to narrow the search (Appendix 2).
Additionally, the reference lists of vital articles were also explored for relevant articles that could have been overlooked during the preliminary search. After this secondary search, the articles that met our eligibility criteria were included in the study. The research selection method was reported using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) flowchart [18], as shown in Fig. 1.

Stage 3: Selecting studies
The articles that used keywords or words similar to these were recognised at this stage. Three-stage screening (titles, abstract and full text) was carried out. Moreover, the full contents were examined to determine the articles' fitness for inclusion in our study. The articles were deliberated according to the predetermined eligibility criteria (Table 1). To further ensure the credibility of selected articles, all articles were directly downloaded from the journal site through the full-text link provided by each database, and any retracted/withdrawn articles as well as from the predatory and dubious journals were excluded from the article list. A total of 2,134 articles were initially found based on the search terms used. Then the duplicates were removed, leaving behind 1,889 articles. Of these, 1,148 titles were chosen based on the eligibility requirements, and the abstracts of such articles were recovered. After reviewing the abstracts to determine if they satisfied the suitability measures (Table 1), more articles were removed. Based on the eligibility criteria, 137 abstracts were carefully chosen, and the full texts of the corresponding articles were vetted according to the suitability criteria for full-article selection (Table 1). A total of 24 articles were then included in the study (see Fig. 2). Two reviewers collected full-text articles at this stage [20]. These final search results were exported to the bibliographic software EndNote (Clarivate Analytics, Philadelphia, PA). A third reviewer was available to resolve differences of opinion (but no difference occurred). The inter-rater reliability of the two reviewers was 0.871, with an intraclass correlation coefficient of Fig. 1 Illustration of a codes-to-theory model for codification and categorisation during the thematic analysis [19] 0.852 (p < 0.001) (Koo & Li, 2016). The study ultimately used 24 articles for data extraction and charting.

Stage 4: Charting the data
The use of an organised charting method established a priori aided in extracting relevant data from the included studies [17]. Initially, 12 randomly chosen articles were individually studied by two researchers, who drafted the data abstraction form to ensure that their data extraction method is constantly reliable and consistent with the research question. The final form involved two broad headings: study features (authors and year and location of publication) and research area focus (aims, objective, purpose, sample, study design, tools, and CSs used). The coding procedure consisted of three key phases: open coding, creating categories and abstraction [22]. Open coding was carried out by three researchers, who individually read the articles, took down notes and wrote the headings to designate the main research area for each article. The headings and notes were then documented to produce a list of preliminary codes. The list was then refined through a cyclical process by merging similar codes into subcategories. Next, we held debriefing meetings to lay out the necessary explanations, make coding decisions, and develop categories. As we already had a research question, we adopted an inductive approach. Finally, coding was conducted using the inductive qualitative data analysis software NVivo [23]. The details of the extracts from the included articles are exhibited in Appendix 1.

Stage 5: Collating, summarizing, and reporting the results
At this stage, we recognised the thematic categories in the relevant literature involving various segments, comprising the study methods, evidence, results, and implications. The thematic analysis was conducted in six steps, as suggested by Saldana (2009) [24]: (1) interpreting the texts; (2) tagging the meaningful texts into codes; (3) determining the most significant codes and generating and assembling the associated codes into categories; (4) tagging the categories and determining their relevance and relations; (5) determining the hierarchy, importance or representation of the categories into themes and (6) arranging the results into meaningful themes. Illustration of a codes-to-theory model for codification and categorisation during the thematic analysis is depicted in Fig. 2 When all the data had been assembled, and some opening information had been recognised, we held online meetings to discuss the data analysis and interpretation strategies to employ in the study, the study results obtained, and the writing of this manuscript for publication purposes. The data analysis mainly involved qualitative thematic analysis. To include a statement of the evidence and the possible

Steps of determining study suitability Inclusion criteria
Title suitability Articles: Published within the period from January 1, 1986, to March 31, 2021 Used the English language With the overwhelming theme relating to coping strategies and mental health disorders Abstract suitability Abstracts: Abstracts of the original article available in a peer-reviewed journal Abstracts of articles on studies conducted internationally or nationally Abstracts of articles on studies within the context of undergraduate medical education Abstracts of articles on studies with medical students and faculty as the participants Abstracts of articles on studies that carried out a thorough evaluation of coping strategies and mental health disorders Full-text suitability Studies: With full-text articles available Elaborating effective coping strategies With a robust analytical approach of the result(s)

With a well-designed exploration intervention
With evidence of evaluation of coping strategies for mental health disorders Reporting coping strategies and, or mental health disorders inconsistencies in the existing knowledge, the interventions and other findings with similar characteristics were arranged thematically. This method helped us gather more structured data and allowed us to come up with the main themes (mental health disorders [MHDs] and CSs) and with substantial results and explicit information connected to our research question (to be explained in the subsequent sections).

Results of the thematic analysis
With a thematic analysis, we looked for patterns in the data that can be used to shed light on our research. Analysis was conducted in different stages. This process of 'code-to-theory' is illustrated in Fig. 3, and the steps carried out were: (1) interpreting the texts; at this stage, authors read and re-read the texts from the available studies. Making notes and jotting down early impressions were found to be beneficial. (2) tagging the meaningful texts into codes; at this point, we began to organize our data in a meaningful and systematic manner. Every line of text was not coded. We were interested in answering specific research questions, so we used a theoretical thematic analysis rather than inductive. As a result, we coded any data segment relevant to our research question or captured something intriguing about it. This step reduced a significant volume of data into manageable parts of information relevant to the needed perspective and research questions. (3) determining the most significant codes and generating and assembling the associated General Health Questionnaire and list of potential stressors [32] Source and Severity of Stress Scale [29] Questionnaire for perceived stress scale, Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale, sources of stress [31] Stress and coping questionnaire, depression screening [3] Maslach Burnout Inventory-Student Version [36] Major Depression Inventory, Beck Anxiety Inventory [37] Malay version of Hospital Anxiety Depression Scale [41] Cognitive Emotion Regulation Questionnaire [40] Student Adaptation to College Questionnaire [42] Maslach Burnout Inventory-Human Services Survey [19] Medical Student Stress Questionnaire [43] Kessler 10-Psychological Distress Questionnaire [44] Coping strategies b Coping inventory [13,19,29,31,32,42,44] Coping behaviour inventory [43] Coping strategy scales [38] Ways-of-coping scale [4] Standard questionnaire on religious coping methods [39] Potential functional-and dysfunctional-behaviour-based coping strategies questionnaire [36] Problem-focused styles-of-coping inventory [37] Malay version of Brief Religious Coping Scale [41] A strategic approach to coping scale [40] Self-developed questionnaire [44] codes into categories; here, we were able to find the most frequent codes without losing meaningful data. This also helped us capture significant concerns, further developing into prominent categories. (4) tagging the categories and determining their relevance and relations; at this point, the authors work towards finding out frequent categories and the underlying meaning. It was also established which categories were related to each other and were oriented to a particular concept. (5) determining the hierarchy, importance, or representation into themes. We had the most significant themes at this crucial stage with an order of occurrence, representing the extracted information from the included studies. The significance was based on their representation concerning the research questions. (6) arranging the results into meaningful themes. At this stage, we found a fitting answer to our research question in the form of extracted points relating to the two main themes: MHDs and CSs. These two themes embody the most discussed issues about psychological morbidity with coping in the undergraduate medical-education context within the published literature. The identified themes yielded subthemes. Theme 1 (MHDs) had four subthemes: burnout, stress, depression and anxiety. Theme 2 (CSs), on the other hand, had eight subthemes: support (social and emotional) seeking; active coping; acceptance; avoidance/denial; substance abuse; faith/religion; sports, leisure, games (mobile device/personal computer [PC]) and miscellaneous.

Frequently addressed mental health disorders
Mental health issues are becoming more common among medical students and can have a detrimental effect on their overall mental health, affecting their everyday learning and practice tasks. As shown in Table 3, stress, depression, anxiety, and burnout emerged as MHD (theme 1) subthemes in this study. MHDs and their subthemes, when faced by undergraduate medical students, were tackled with various CSs (to be described in the subsequent section).

Frequently used coping strategies
All the 24 included studies highlighted the various CSs employed by undergraduate medical students to tackle challenging events. We identified the CSs employed as a theme in the included studies and classified these into eight subthemes: support (social and emotional) seeking; active coping; acceptance; avoidance/denial; substance abuse; faith/religion; sports, leisure, games (mobile device/PC) and miscellaneous. Table 4 shows the CDs frequently reported by undergraduate medical students.

Effective coping strategies
CSs have effects (positive or negative) on individuals' mental health. We found that some of them can successfully decrease the adverse effects of stresses on Fig. 3 Steps of the 'codes to theory' process. Saldana [24] 6 step process carried out for thematic analysis well-being, whereas others cannot. Table 5 summarises the effective CSs drawn from the included studies.

Discussion
To the best of our knowledge, this study was the first to explore the CSs most frequently used by undergraduate medical students for MHDs, and the most effective ones among them. The central imperative themes extracted from the 24 included studies were primarily on how essential CSs are for undergraduate medical students in times of need. Medical students face various challenges that affect their mental health during their academic life, and CSs are basic methods of coping with MHDs [45].
Most of the studies that were included in our study highlighted various MHDs (stress [3,13,25,28,29,31,32,34,35,43,44], depression [3,27,34,37,38,41], anxiety [31,34,37,40,41] and burnout [19,27,36]). It was noted that the subtheme of stress was frequently addressed and is common in professions requiring continuous near-human contact and emotional commitment. Various types of stress are frequently reported in the literature, including those from peers, daily life and the environment [46] and those involving finding new friends and learning new responsibilities [47]; finding oneself in unfamiliar circumstances, having to relate with people one does not know and economic worries [48]; interactions with friends and tutors [49] and poor relationships with the clinical staff [50]. It is important to address the stress experienced by medical students. It can undeniably influence their current academic performance and may lead to substance abuse [51], resulting in their declined empathy in their clinical years [11]. Stress has damaging effects on cognitive performance (e.g. attention and decision making) and mental and physical well-being when it is excessive or unresolved due to poor coping [52]. Studies have found that stress does not stand alone, and high-stress levels can lead to other forms of MHD, such as depression, anxiety and burnout [53].
Depression is associated with stress [3,54]. As medical students are exposed to death and sadness, they are more likely to experience depression than other students [55] and the general population [56], which affects their quality of life [57]. Anxiety is also coupled with isolation and may harm students' self-confidence and affect their academic performance [31]. Some of the included studies also addressed burnout as a form of MHD. Physician wellness has earned much attention in the past few years [19]. The World Health Organization recently documented burnout as an in-service medical syndrome [58]. It is defined as a state of physical fatigue and mental distress caused mainly by work and professional demands [59]. However, medical students also experience burnout and are often hesitant to seek counselling and treatment. Hence, burnout tends to damage their health. Medical students suffer from this stigma, which often stops them from availing themselves of mental health services [27].
The most significant finding in this study is that undergraduate medical students go through challenging times in medical school. The included studies found that availing of different types of support (social and emotional, from friends, family members and fellow students) is the CS most often used by medical students [3,4]. The pattern of actions carried out when one seeks social help is referred to as support utilisation [60]. Many medical students in the included studies joined study groups for social assistance to study. However, seeking social support involves challenges, such as the long duration of academic study and the tendency for medical students to lose their connections with their peers who had given them social support in medical school.
We discovered, however, that medical students use various CSs other than seeking support, such as active coping, acceptance, avoidance, substance abuse, religious coping and engaging in sports. The students in the included studies differed broadly in their CS use.

Positive coping strategy a Negative coping strategy b Study Country (region)
Planned problem solving Escape, avoidance [25] USA (North America) Problem-focused activities Brooding over problems [38] Hong Kong (Eastern Asia) Active coping strategies (acceptance, planning, self-distraction) Avoidance (denial, alcohol use, drug use, behavioural disengagement) [32] UK (Northern Europe) Spending time with friends Isolation [35] Pakistan (South-Central Asia) Positive reframing Taking drugs, alcohol [13] Nepal (South-Central Asia) Talking to friends Engaging in physical exercise, consuming tobacco [28] India (South-Central Asia) Communicating with others Detached coping [26] USA (North America) Positive coping, religious coping Substance use, negative coping, blaming [29] India (South-Central Asia) Adaptive coping Maladaptive coping [30] India (South-Central Asia) Approach-oriented coping Being avoidance-oriented [27] USA (North America) Positive religious coping Negative religious coping [39] Iran (South-Central Asia) Seeking support (from friends, family and fellow students), engaging in relaxing exercises, engaging in sports Religion and mental health have long been seen as partners, with constructive faith coping offering muchneeded comfort during difficult times [65,66]. Pargament explains that religious coping means using faith as a source of strength during stressful times [67]. However, the studies on the effectiveness of religious coping for people in traumatic circumstances have shown mixed results. According to Francis et al. (2019), religious coping is effective in the Southeast Asian region [41] because it is the conventional geographical centre point for many religions and cultures.
Positive religious coping entails evaluating challenges considering God's providence and establishing a stable relationship with God. On the other hand, negative religious coping is maladaptive and sees obstacles as a form of retribution for one's disobedience of God's commands [68]. The medical students in the included studies showed more positive than negative religious coping, as demonstrated by their relevant mean score [41].
Engaging in sports and leisure activities is also among the useful CSs utilised by medical students. Engaging in sports (or exercising) was placed third among the CSs used by such students and seen as a helpful CS [28]. In another study, the most repeatedly mentioned CS was spending time with one's friends, followed by sleeping, listening to music, engaging in sports and isolating oneself. The female participants opted to study and sleep, whereas the male participants preferred to socialise with their friends, engage in sports or detach themselves from others [35].
We found that social support negatively correlates with depression and exhaustion in medical students. A considerable body of research has emerged showing the positive impact of social support on well-being in healthy and ill people [69][70][71]. In exploring the relationships between depression, anxiety, family functioning, social support and coping styles among Chinese medical students, it was found that depression is significantly negatively correlated with social support [72].
We also found that the medical students in the included studies explicitly chose active coping, acceptance and avoidance while tackling various MHDs. A study [73] surveyed undergraduate and graduate entry students. Both groups registered similar levels of MHDs, but the strategies that they used to cope with such MHDs differed. The graduate entry students were more likely to use active coping and positive reframing but were more likely to use substances (alcohol and drugs) to help them cope. In contrast, the undergraduate students were more likely to use religion (i.e. praying or meditating) as a way of coping. Other studies have also shown that undergraduate medical students in the United Kingdom use much alcohol, cannabis and other illicit substances [74,75]. The occurrence of mental illness and drug abuse among medical students can vary from that in the general population in some ways. For example, American medical students use alcohol, benzodiazepines and prescription opiates at higher rates than other similar-age cohorts [76]. A predicted reason that substance abuse is common among medical students is the inappropriate teaching about substance abuse. Medical students generally accept that the teaching of drug abuse in medical schools is generally insufficient [77]. Overall, however, drug abuse is linked to psychosocial impairments such as study stress and job pressure, and illegal drugs are taken to relieve discomfort and cope with isolation, stress, anxiety and depression [64].
Engaging in physical activities, sports, and socialising is essential for personal development and growth [78]. Engaging in sports has been shown to have stress relief and overall health benefits. We likewise found that participating in sports is also used as a CS by medical students. It was reported that participating in sports is a common CS among them [35]. A study from Saudi Arabia reported sports as among the leisure activities engaged in by undergraduate medical students as CSs [79].
CSs have effects (positive or negative) on individuals' mental health. We found that they work both ways: some CSs can successfully lower the adverse effects of stress on mental well-being, whereas others cannot. The extent to which CSs can detach people from worries may be associated with their perception of their control over the events causing them to worry and maybe favourably connected with their psychological well-being.
Being able to cope with stress positively can help medical students prevent the occurrence of dire implications for their mental health. This can help them feel better physically and psychologically and positively affect their performance at their best. Research shows that students with an active coping style (those who can confront problems positively and straightforwardly) have less emotional distress [80].
Sometimes, one may find it hard to resist engaging in a negative CS that will give one instant relief but may pose bigger challenges for oneself down the road. The well-known inventory for coping (Brief COPE) developed by Pargament [67,68] allows the assessment of negative and positive coping, with equal distributions of items (i.e. seven for each). This inventory appears to be frequently utilised by studies (see Appendix 1). The negative CSs (shown and expressed in Table 5 as less frequent/lowest scoring/non-supportive/dysfunctional) reported by the included studies were 'escape and avoidance' [4, 19, 25-27, 32, 40, 43], 'drugs and alcohol' [3,13,29,31,32,34,36,81] and 'negative religious couping' [39,41].
The included studies explained that perceived stress is linked to academic, psychosocial and environmental stressors. Therefore, the academic curriculum and assessment patterns must be reframed, and counselling cells must be established within the school. In addition, leisure and sports activities must be incorporated into the medical curriculum to make medical education less tense, which can be achieved by providing additional time and resources for leisure and sports.

Future directions
Despite the substantial body of research demonstrating a positive relationship between support and happiness, we still know very little about the mechanisms by which support influences psychological and physical health. More attention should be given to those who are disabled by drug abuse or mental illness, and renewed efforts are needed to emphasise their prevention and early diagnosis and the care given to those afflicted with them. According to our findings, health support programs and proper guidance on using effective and positive CSs will improve undergraduate medical students' psychological resilience. That is, their mental health and psychological well-being will benefit from these. However, the authors believe that a meta-analysis is needed to shed more light on this topic.

Strengths and limitations
This study used a well-known and commonly accepted approach for scoping several articles to synthesise the available data on the issue of the CSs most frequently used by undergraduate medical students. We had two reviewers at every level, and searching for original studies from more than one database gives evidence of our study's meticulousness, which can be considered a strength of our study. Nevertheless, we cite herein the limitations of our study. Firstly, only English-language research articles were reviewed. Because coping has grown as a universally popular domain for researchers, there may be relevant studies in languages other than English.
Secondly, this scoping review utilised three central databases accessible to the authors when this review was conducted; therefore, including more databases might enrich the review outcomes. Finally, despite the extensive search approach and inclusion criteria, we did not find many studies from Middle Eastern and Southeast Asian countries. This may also be linked to English being not the first language in such countries.

Conclusion
Undergraduate medical students worldwide experience a wide range of MHDs (stress, depression, anxiety, and burnout) and during such challenging times, try a variety of CSs. The most common is support (social and emotional) seeking, active coping, acceptance, avoidance, substance abuse, religious coping and sports engagement. It is important to emphasise that aside from educating medical students in a professional medical course, their quality of life during their medical training must also be considered. Thus, teaching medical students how to deal with adversity is critical. Individual and administrative involvement is essential for preventing MHDs among medical students.

Abbreviations
CSs: Coping Strategies; PRISMA: Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis; Misc: Miscellaneous.