Skip to main content

Table 2 Video B

From: Pilot study of the DART tool - an objective healthcare simulation debriefing assessment instrument

Rater

Format

Role

Rater

Exp. (years)

Rater Sex (m/f/o)

Instructor Questions (IQ)

Instructor Statements (IS)

Trainee Responses (TR)

IQ:IS Ratio

TR:[IQ + IS]

Ratio

1

video

MD

21

M

6

37

22

0.16

0.51

2

video

MD

10

F

6

13

19

0.46

1.00

3

video

MD

15

F

12

14

19

0.86

0.73

4

video

RN

6

F

8

12

10

0.67

0.50

5

video

MD

9

M

7

16

11

0.44

0.48

6

video

MD

3

M

5

12

11

0.42

0.65

Sum

 

64

 

44.0

104.0

92.0

3.00

3.87

Mean

10.7

7.3

17.3

15.5

0.50

0.64

SD

6.47

2.5

9.8

5.3

0.24

0.20

CV%

34.1%

56.3%

34.2%

47.5%

31.0%

  1. Global Impression of Debriefing Quality: ‘Facilitator(s) lead strongly and appear to dominate the debriefing to the point of providing mini-lectures rather than facilitating reflection. Performance gaps were briefly addressed’