From: Peer evaluation and feedback for invasive medical procedures: a systematic review
Subspecialty | Source | Procedure | Research Design | Evaluation Method | Feedback Method | Study Quality* |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cardiology | Blows 2012 | PCI | Retrospective | Angiography and PCI review | Benchmarked report | 4 |
Doll 2017 | PCI | Retrospective | Case conference | M&M conference | 4 | |
Doll 2019 | Coronary Angiography and PCI | Retrospective | Angiography and clinical record review | M&M conference | 4 | |
Puri 2016 | PCI | Retrospective | Clinical record review | None | 4 | |
Rader 2014 | Coronary Angiography | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Gastroenterology | Barton 2012 | Colonoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Live, in-person review | None | 2b |
Boyle 2012 | Colonoscopy | Prospective | Live, in-person review | None | 2b | |
Duloy 2018 | Polypectomy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Duloy 2019 | Polypectomy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | Report card | 2b | |
Fleischer 1992 | Various endoscopies | Retrospective | Case conference | M&M conference | 4 | |
Gupta 2011 | Polypectomy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Gupta 2012 | Polypectomy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Keswani 2020 | Colonoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Lee 2011 | Colonoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Mai 1991 | Colonoscopy, endoscopies | Retrospective | Clinical record review | Monthly Meeting | 4 | |
Patel 2019 | Cold-snare polypectomy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Rex 2000 | Colonoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 3b | |
Rex 2010 | Colonoscopy | Prospective | Video review | None | 2b | |
Sapienza 1992 | Colonoscopy, endoscopic gastrostomy, sigmoidoscopy, and upper endoscopy | Retrospective | Case conference | Letter | 4 | |
Sarker 2008 | Colonoscopy and flexible sigmoidoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Live, in-person review | None | 2b | |
Scaffidi 2018 | Colonoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Live, in-person review (non-blinded) and retrospective video review (blinded) | None | 2b | |
Shah 2002 | Colonoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Takao 2020 | ESD | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Thomas-Gibson 2006 | Flexible sigmoidoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b | |
Vassiliou 2010 | Colonoscopy, upper endoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Live, in-person review | None | 2b | |
Walsh 2015 | Colonoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Live, in-person review | None | 2b | |
Interventional Radiology | Caruso 2016 | Various IR procedures | Retrospective | Multi-component review | M&M conference | 4 |
d'Othée 2013 | Various IR procedures | Retrospective | Case conference | Daily conference | 4 | |
Luo 2019 | Various IR procedures | Retrospective | Case conference | Daily conference | 4 | |
Pulmonology | Konge 2012 (1) | Bronchoscopy | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b |
Konge 2012 (2) | FNA guided by EUS | Prospective, agreement testing | Direct observation & video review | None | 2b | |
Konge 2015 | EBUS-TBNA | Prospective, agreement testing | Video review | None | 2b |