Skip to main content

Table 1 Studies of peer evaluation for invasive medical procedures

From: Peer evaluation and feedback for invasive medical procedures: a systematic review

Subspecialty

Source

Procedure

Research Design

Evaluation Method

Feedback Method

Study Quality*

Cardiology

Blows 2012

PCI

Retrospective

Angiography and PCI review

Benchmarked report

4

Doll 2017

PCI

Retrospective

Case conference

M&M conference

4

Doll 2019

Coronary Angiography and PCI

Retrospective

Angiography and clinical record review

M&M conference

4

Puri 2016

PCI

Retrospective

Clinical record review

None

4

Rader 2014

Coronary Angiography

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Gastroenterology

Barton 2012

Colonoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Live, in-person review

None

2b

Boyle 2012

Colonoscopy

Prospective

Live, in-person review

None

2b

Duloy 2018

Polypectomy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Duloy 2019

Polypectomy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

Report card

2b

Fleischer 1992

Various endoscopies

Retrospective

Case conference

M&M conference

4

Gupta 2011

Polypectomy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Gupta 2012

Polypectomy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Keswani 2020

Colonoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Lee 2011

Colonoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Mai 1991

Colonoscopy, endoscopies

Retrospective

Clinical record review

Monthly Meeting

4

Patel 2019

Cold-snare polypectomy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Rex 2000

Colonoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

3b

Rex 2010

Colonoscopy

Prospective

Video review

None

2b

Sapienza 1992

Colonoscopy, endoscopic gastrostomy, sigmoidoscopy, and upper endoscopy

Retrospective

Case conference

Letter

4

Sarker 2008

Colonoscopy and flexible sigmoidoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Live, in-person review

None

2b

Scaffidi 2018

Colonoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Live, in-person review (non-blinded) and retrospective video review (blinded)

None

2b

Shah 2002

Colonoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Takao 2020

ESD

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Thomas-Gibson 2006

Flexible sigmoidoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Vassiliou 2010

Colonoscopy, upper endoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Live, in-person review

None

2b

Walsh 2015

Colonoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Live, in-person review

None

2b

Interventional Radiology

Caruso 2016

Various IR procedures

Retrospective

Multi-component review

M&M conference

4

d'Othée 2013

Various IR procedures

Retrospective

Case conference

Daily conference

4

Luo 2019

Various IR procedures

Retrospective

Case conference

Daily conference

4

Pulmonology

Konge 2012 (1)

Bronchoscopy

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

Konge 2012 (2)

FNA guided by EUS

Prospective, agreement testing

Direct observation & video review

None

2b

Konge 2015

EBUS-TBNA

Prospective, agreement testing

Video review

None

2b

  1. *Rating scale from the Oxford Center for Evidence-based Medicine [18]
  2. Abbreviations: PCI Percutaneous coronary intervention, M&M Morbidity & Mortality, ESD Endoscopic submucosal dissection, IR Interventional radiology, FNA Fine-needle aspiration, EUS Endoscopic ultrasound, EBUS-TBNA Endobronchial ultrasound-guided transbronchial needle aspiration