From: Educational adaptation to clinical training during the COVID-19 pandemic: a process analysis
Classic Kotter | Feature | Change During COVID-19 | Implication |
---|---|---|---|
Establish a Sense of Urgency | ● Consider potential future scenarios and untapped opportunities | ● Urgency palpable | ● Imperative for change was obvious |
● Level of clinical and personal danger prevalent | |||
● Make the need for change clearly known | ● Imperiled educational goals and metrics | ||
Form a Powerful Guiding Coalition | ● Assemble a strong group of individuals | ● Coalition emerges through differential engagement of participants | ● Self-organized frontline coalition formed with technology adept teachers and learners in the lead efforts |
● Ensure the coalition will work well as a team towards the shared goal | |||
● Co-creation prevalent | |||
● Facility with technology ability a key differentiator initially | |||
Create a Strategic Vision | ● Build a vision to guide change efforts | ● Initial lack of strategic vision | ● Initial focus reactionary rather than aligned Cross-disciplinary themes emerged |
● Envision and share a strategy for success | ● Vision emerges as needs and goals identified through top-down communication | ||
● Settling out process | |||
Communicate the Vision | ● Communicate expectations ten times more than expected | ● Bilateral communication including trickle-up of what was working | ● Regular communications channels established both within and across specialties |
● Vary communication strategies | ● Communicating uncertainty was reassuring | ||
● Guiding coalition role models new behaviors | |||
Empower Others to Act on the Vision | ● Remove or alter organizational obstacles | ● New telemedicine, information management, and education roles for clinical trainees | ● Co-creation of educational work designed to support rapidly identified clinical need |
● Support experimentation and rapid improvement cycles | |||
● More self-regulated and self-directed learning | ● More flipped classroom implementations | ||
● Medical students identify need for and implement educational sessions | |||
● Increase in learner ownership | |||
● Allocate designated roles by best fit helps flatten hierarchy | |||
Plan for and Generate Short-Term Wins | ● Showcase short term, visible improvements | ● Initially maintain moral through “non-losses” | ● Continue educational mission without lapse |
● Publicly reward those who enable and support wins | ● Level of engagement an important early guiding indicator of success | ● Celebrate trial, error, and growth | |
● Inclusive participation of teachers and learners within sessions | |||
● Realize advantages of online learning | |||
Consolidate Improvements and Produce Still More Change | ● Promote those who are effective change agents | ● Identify what is working | ● Increase in attendance at rounds and conferences |
● Challenge long-held assumptions about how clinical education should occur | ● Use of chat, poll, and screenshare features | ||
● Energize the change by offering resources and supporting new projects | ● Engage discussant, moderator, and reviewer roles to support integrated learning | ||
Institutionalize New Approaches | ● Sustain change by ensuring new approaches are understood by all | ● Organizational change requires a predisposition to accepting change as a constant | ● Accept iteration and ambiguity inherent in educational process |
● Trial new methods, learn from failures, and share what worked | |||
● Vocalize connections between new changes and organizational success | |||
● Adaptation integrated into the clinician-educator role | ● Recognize fallibility and humanize education |