AUBMC | HDF | p-value | |
---|---|---|---|
Prior participation in DNR decision | |||
No Yes | 15(15%) 85(85%) | 8(11.9%) 59(88.1%) | 0.574† |
Attitude toward DNR decision | |||
- Ready for physician-initiated discussion with mentally competent patient. | 68(68%) | 23(34.3%) | 0.000† |
- Ready for patient-initiated discussion with mentally competent patient | 21(21%) | 29(43.3%) | 0.002† |
- Would discuss upon serious clinical deterioration without involving the patient | 12(12%) | 16(23.9%) | 0.044† |
- Uncertain about what to do | 5(5%) | 6(9%) | 0.313† |
Criteria that preclude patient participation in decision | |||
- Not comfortable with the decision | 19(36.5%) | 19(33.3%) | 0.157† |
- Lack of time on the part of the attending physician | 4(7.7%) | 7(12.3%) | 0.100† |
- Respect the wishes of the family who refuse to involve the patient. | 24(46.2%) | 41(71.9%) | 0.000† |
- Refusal to discuss prognosis with patient | 7(13.5%) | 6(10.5%) | 0.644† |
- Refusal to inform the patient of his diagnosis | 10(19.2%) | 3(5.3%) | 0.192† |
- Personal belief that the patient does not want to be engaged in these discussions | 12(23.1%) | 10(17.5%) | 0.584† |
- Personal conviction that the discussion is traumatic and a source of anxiety for the patient | 17(32.7%) | 25(43.9%) | 0.003† |
- Physician is better placed through the doctor-patient relationship to determine the course of treatment in the patient's best interest | 18(34.6%) | 18(31.6%) | 0.172† |
- Certain personal characteristics of the patient (ethnicity, culture, religion, age, socioeconomic level | 8(15.4%) | 14(24.6%) | 0.016† |
Opinion of physician in charge | |||
Not important at all Somewhat important Important Very important Fundamental | 2(2%) 7(7.1%) 22(22.4%) 39(39.8%) 28(28.6%) | 1(1.5%) 3(4.5%) 10(15.2%) 29(43.9%) 23(34.8%) | 0.177‡ |
Opinion of medical team (Physicians) | |||
Not important at all Somewhat important Important Very important Fundamental | 0(0%) 16(16.2%) 28(28.3%) 35(35.4%) 20(20.2%) | 1(1.5%) 2(3%) 15(22.4%) 30(44.8%) 19(28.4%) | 0.018‡ |