Skip to main content

Table 3 Results of the First and Second Delphi Surveys

From: Curriculum development on the human rights of people with disabilities for future medical education: using a modified Delphi

 

Topic

First Delphi*

Second Delphi**

CVR

Results

CVR

Results

Necessity

Adequacy

Necessity

Adequacy

- Basic Introductory Course

1

Concept of disability and understanding of disability

1.00

1.00

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

2

Definition and characteristics of disability

0.75

0.88

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

3

Laws and policies related to people with disabilities at home and abroad

0.75

0.63

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

4

Health of people with disabilities

1.00

1.00

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

5

Obstacles to using medical services I

1.00

0.88

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

6

Obstacles to using medical services II (special lecture by people with disabilities)

1.00

0.88

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

7

Understanding assistive technology devices for people with disabilities

0.63

0.38

Reevaluation required

0.63

0.73

Selected (second)

8

Disability experience education I

0.25

0.25

Reevaluation required

0.73

0.60

Selected (second)

9

Etiquette for various disabilities

0.63

0.50

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

10

Communication with people with disabilities

0.88

0.63

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

11

Disability experience education II

0.00

0.00

Deleted

–

–

Deleted (first)

12

Community service

0.63

0.38

Reevaluation required

0.63

1.00

Selected (second)

13

Meeting people with disabilities in the community

0.25

0.38

Reevaluation required

0.87

0.73

Selected (second)

14

Research related to people with disabilities

0.50

0.25

Reevaluation required

0.50

0.73

Selected (second)

- Care and Communication for Patients with Disabilities Course

1

What is communication?

0.71

0.71

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

2

Building rapport with patients with disabilities

1.00

0.86

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

3

Communication with patients with disabilities: type I (patients with visual impairment)

1.00

0.86

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

4

Communication with patients with disabilities: type II (patients with hearing impairment)

0.86

0.71

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

5

Communication with patients with disabilities: type III (patients with developmental disorders)

0.86

0.71

Reevaluation required

1.00

0.85

Selected (second)

6

Patient consent I (theory)

0.71

0.57

Reevaluation required

1.00

0.85

Selected (second)

7

Patient consent II (consent for CT scan)

0.29

0.29

Deleted

–

–

Deleted (first)

8

Patient consent III (organ donation)

−0.14

−0.29

Deleted

–

–

Deleted (first)

9

Basic principles of treatment of patients with disabilities

1.00

1.00

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

10

Treatment of patients with disabilities: type I

1.00

1.00

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

11

Treatment of patients with disabilities: type II

0.57

0.57

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

12

Meeting patients with disabilities

0.43

0.43

Reevaluation required

0.54

0.69

Selected (second)

13

Mock interviews using standardized patients I (patients with visual impairment)

0.71

0.57

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

14

Mock interviews using standardized patients II (patients with intellectual disabilities)

0.86

0.57

Selected

–

–

Selected (first)

  1. * minimum CVR: 0.49 (first and second survey)
  2. ** minimum CVR: 0.51 (first survey), 0.54 (second survey)