Skip to main content

Table 3 COSMIN methodological quality ratings

From: Professional identity measures for student health professionals – a systematic review of psychometric properties

Psychometric study COSMIN Rating Measure
Adams et al. [1] Good Macleod Clark Professional Identity Scale
Cao et al. [28] Fair Nurse Self Concept Questionnaire
Cowin et al. [16] Excellent Clarity of Professional Identity
Macleod Clark Professional Identity Scale
Nurses’ Professional Values Scale – Revised
The Values Survey
Cowin [20] Good Nurse Self Concept Questionnaire
Crossley & Vivekananda-Schmidt [24] Fair Professional Self Identity Questionnaire
Dobrow & Higgins [19] Good Clarity of Professional Identity
Geckil et al. [30] Good Nurses’ Professional Values Scale – Revised
Hao et al. [23] Fair Professional Identity Scale for Nursing Students
Lin et al. [29] Good Nurses’ Professional Values Scale – Revised
Moon et al. [31] Fair Nurses’ Professional Values Scale – Revised
Onyeizugbo & Nwafor [27] Poor Nurse Self Concept Questionnaire
Rognstad et al. [25] Good The Values Survey
Tan et al. [22] Good Professional Identity Five Factor Scale
Weis & Schank [21] Good Nurses’ Professional Values Scale – Revised
Worthington et al. [26] Good Macleod Clark Professional Identity Scale