Skip to main content

Table 1 Weighting of annual mean I-ITE scores based on other International exam centers and Annual Mean Weighted Rwandan I-ITE scores

From: Measuring change in knowledge acquisition of Rwandan residents: using the American Board of Pediatrics International In-Training Examination (I-ITE) as an independent tool to monitor individual and departmental improvements during the Human Resources for Health program: an observational study

 

2012–13

2013–14

2015–16

2016–17

2017–18

p-value

 

International Countries

Italy

Bahamas

Italy

Bahamas

Bahamas

Not applicable

Kuwait

Italy

Kuwait

Italy

Italy

Lebanon

Kuwait

Lebanon

Kuwait

Kuwait

Oman

Lebanon

Oman

Lebanon

Lebanon

Qatar

Oman

Qatar

Qatar

Qatar

Singapore

Qatar

Singapore

Singapore

Saudi Arabia

UAE

Singapore

UAE

UAE

 
 

UAE

   

All residents

US scores

66.0 (±10) (n = 9138)

62.0 (±10) (n = 9300)

66.0 (±10) (n = 9138)

60.2 (±8) (n = 10,965)

65.0 (±8) (n = 11,014)

p < 0.001b

Non-Rwandan International scores

60.8 (±11) (n = 1024)

59.8 (±10) (n = 1128)

64.8 (±11) (n = 823)

56.9 (±10) (n = 502)

62.1 (±11) (n = 704)

p < 0.001b

Annual weighting factor

0.998

0.983

1.064

0.935

1.020

Rwandan non-weighted (raw) scorses

34.3 (±7.5) (n = 27)

38.8 (±8.6) (n = 41)

47.1 (±9.0) (n = 50)

43.5 (±7.0) (n = 49)

49.5 (±6.2) (n = 46)

p < 0.001a

Rwandan weighted scores

34.3 (±7.5) (n = 27)

39.5 (±8.7) (n = 41)

44.3 (±8.4) (n = 50)

46.5 (±7.4) (n = 49)

48.6 (±6.1) (n = 46)

p < 0.001a

Rwandan mean z-score

−2.57 (CI: − 2.85 to − 2.28) (n = 27)

−2.18 (CI: − 2.46 to − 1.89) (n = 41)

−1.78 (CI: − 2.04 to − 1.52) (n = 50)

−1.38 (CI: − 1.59 to − 1.17) (n = 49)

−1.30 (CI: − 1.50 to − 1.11) (n = 46)

p < 0.001a

PG1 residents

US PG1 scores

59 (±8) (n = 2993)

54 (±8) (n = 3062)

59 (±8) (n = 2993)

55 (±7) (n = 3545)

61 (±8) (n = 3595)

p < 0.001b

Non-Rwandan International PG1 scores

57 (±10) (n = 286)

55 (±10) (n = 299)

59 (±10) (n = 214)

52 (±10) (n = 127)

55 (±10) (n = 167)

p < 0.001b

Rwandan weighted PG1 scores

34.8 (±8.4) (n = 16)

35.1 (±7.2) (n = 14)

40.6 (±4.9) (n = 15)

43.7 (±7.9) (n = 12)

44.3 (±6.7) (n = 7)

p = 0.002a

Rwandan PG1 mean z-scores

−2.15 (CI: −2.59 to −1.73) (n = 16)

− 2.00 (CI: − 2.39 to − 1.60) (n = 14)

−1.60 (CI: − 1.90 to − 1.30) (n = 15)

−1.16 (CI: − 1.64 to −0.67) (n = 12)

−0.98 (CI: − 1.60 to − 0.36) (n = 7)

p < 0.001a

  1. Abbreviations: CI 95% Confidence interval
  2. aANOVA of total mean scores for PG level was undertaken
  3. bPost-hoc ANOVA ± Standard Deviation