Skip to main content

Table 3 Means (± standard deviation) for groups representing the three styles of success in the medical career (year 2009), in terms of coping strategies at admission and during medical school (years 1999–2005)

From: The coping strategies during medical education predict style of success in medical career: a 10-year longitudinal study

 

Dependent variables (2 0 0 9)

 

Independent

variable (1 9 9 9 – 2 0 0 5)

Committed

↓ competence ↑ job satisf.

↑ work stress

2. Clever

↓ competence ↓ job satisf.

↓ work stress

↑ QoL

3. Bright

↑ competence ↓ job satisf.

↓ QoL

   

Committed vs Clever

Committed vs Bright

Clever vs Bright

 

M±SD

M±SD

M±SD

F (2;47)

P

Eta2

Tukey’s

post-

hoc test

Approach Coping

Logical Analysis (cognitive)

         

1999 - Admission

53.43±2.65

53.60±5.53

52.88±5.83

0.097

0.907

    

2000 - First year of medical study

54.14±3.57

52.20±7.41

52.38±5.86

0.481

0.621

    

2001 - Second year of medical study

54.71±5.20

52.80±5.67

54.25±4.37

0.657

0.523

    

2002 - Third year of medical study

54.71±5.20

52.30±6.62

54.25±4.37

0.926

0.403

    

2003 - Fourth year of medical study

52.86±2.85

52.60±6.67

53.63±4.29

0.187

0.830

    

2004 - Fifth year of medical study

54.71±6.02

52.30±6.76

54.38±3.69

0.925

0.404

    

2005 - Sixth year of medical study

55.71±6.22

52.30±6.76

54.38±3.69

1.505

0.232

    

Positive Reappraisal (cognitive)

         

1999 - Admission

51.14±6.46

51.20±5.58

48.00±8.50

1.164

0.321

    

2000 - First year of medical study

49.29±6.97

52.20±6.88

47.75±8.47

1.668

0.200

    

2001 - Second year of medical study

52.00±6.97

51.30±7.06

50.88±6.96

0.098

0.907

    

2002 - Third year of medical study

52.00±6.97

51.30±6.79

50.88± 6.96

0.101

0.904

    

2003 - Fourth year of medical study

50.57±6.25

52.20±6.91

51.25±6.88

0.251

0.779

    

2004 - Fifth year of medical study

53.00±5.71

50.40±6.60

51.25±6.88

0.673

0.515

    

2005 - Sixth year of medical study

52.43±5.63

50.40±6.60

51.25±6.88

0.408

0.667

    

Guidance and Support Seeking (behavioral)

1999 - Admission

54.71±10.01

54.30±8.75

54.63±8.50

0.010

0.990

    

2000 - First year of medical study

54.71±10.75

55.60±6.90

56.50±7.83

0.169

0.845

    

2001 - Second year of medical study

53.14±9.74

55.60±8.84

56.25±6.87

0.547

0.582

    

2002 - Third year of medical study

53.14±9.74

57.90±6.45

56.25±6.87

1.613

0.210

    

2003 - Fourth year of medical study

52.86±9.82

58.40±5.70

55.00±5.24

2.745

0.075

0,12

0,07

0,68

0,32

2004 - Fifth year of medical study

56.00±10.26

56.50±6.51

55.38±5.26

0.102

0.903

    

2005 - Sixth year of medical study

57.14±11.00

56.50±6.51

56.00±5.96

0.079

0.924

    

Problem Solving (behavioral)

         

1999 - Admission

47.29±6.92

54.30±8.74

53.25±4.43

4.382

0.018*

0,19

0,02*

0,07

0,90

2000 - First year of medical study

49.00±8.06

56.60±7.88

55.13±5.25

4.871

0.012*

0,21

0,01*

0,06

0,82

2001 - Second year of medical study

51.86±7.22

54.60±7.14

52.50±5.24

0.824

0.445

    

2002 - Third year of medical study

51.86±7.22

53.80±7.92

52.50±5.24

0.348

0.708

    

2003 - Fourth year of medical study

50.71±6.85

54.80±6.96

52.13±5.15

1.806

0.175

    

2004 - Fifth year of medical study

54.00±6.61

53.80±7.24

53.00±5.22

0.105

0.901

    

2005 - Sixth year of medical study

54.43±6.56

53.80±7.24

53.38±5.61

0.097

0.908

    

Avoidant Coping

Cognitive Avoidance (cognitive)

         

1999 - Admission

51.71±10.69

50.20±6.32

48.38±6.34

0.694

0.505

    

2000 - First year of medical study

51.29±10.88

50.50±5.11

50.75±8.88

0.038

0.963

    

2001 - Second year of medical study

47.29±9.81

50.80±5.23

50.63±8.23

1.006

0.373

    

2002 - Third year of medical study

47.29±9.81

52.20±5.63

50.63±8.23

1.647

0.204

    

2003 - Fourth year of medical study

48.57±8.48

50.90±5.96

52.38±6.87

1.107

0.339

    

2004 - Fifth year of medical study

46.86±7.49

49.80±6.44

51.50±7.38

1.648

0.203

    

2005 - Sixth year of medical study

45.86±8.03

49.80±6.44

50.88±8.04

1.877

0.164

    

Acceptance or Resignation (cognitive)

1999 - Admission

48.86±4.59

44.00±5.29

51.38±7.90

6.863

0.002**

0.29

0.07

0.50

0.00*

2000 - First year of medical study

49.57±5.37

44.80±5.44

50.63±8.67

3.976

0.025*

0.17

0.11

0.90

0.03

2001 - Second year of medical study

43.57±5.43

44.00±4.18

47.63±5.56

3.164

0.051

0.13

0.97

0.08

0.09

2002 - Third year of medical study

43.57±5.43

44.50±4.80

47.63±5.56

2.579

0.087

0.11

0.87

0.10

0.19

2003 - Fourth year of medical study

45.29±7.25

44.50±5.11

48.63±4.62

2.544

0.089

0.11

0.92

0.25

0.09

2004 - Fifth year of medical study

45.14±3.11

44.50±6.84

48.00±5.14

1.954

0.153

    

2005 - Sixth year of medical study

43.86±5.27

44.50±6.84

48.63±4.62

3.188

0.050

0.14

0.95

0.07

0.10

Seeking Alternative Rewards (behavioral)

1999 - Admission

54.57±5.29

56.50±6.76

54.38±7.15

0.586

0.560

    

2000 - First year of medical study

55.86±5.07

58.40±6.73

56.00±6.85

0.906

0.411

    

2001 - Second year of medical study

53.29±5.37

55.90±5.55

52.50±6.87

1.620

0.209

    

2002 - Third year of medical study

53.29±5.37

56.30±4.57

52.50±6.87

2.321

0.109

    

2003 - Fourth year of medical study

52.86±5.36

56.30±3.37

54.25±7.24

1.740

0.187

    

2004 - Fifth year of medical study

54.86±5.13

56.10±6.23

52.38±7.10

1.601

0.212

    

2005 - Sixth year of medical study

55.14±5.96

56.10±6.23

53.00±7.36

1.019

0.369

    

Emotional Discharge (behavioral)

         

1999 - Admission

61.43±11.66

57.00±6.16

65.25±6.88

4.488

0.016*

0.19

0.28

0.42

0.01*

2000 - First year of medical study

61.86±11.29

58.20±4.40

62.25±6.34

1.615

0.210

    

2001 - Second year of medical study

62.57±9.91

56.70±5.75

61.50±5.59

3.425

0.041*

0.15

0.06

0.91

0.12

2002 - Third year of medical study

62.57±9.91

57.90±6.75

61.50±5.59

1.894

0.162

    

2003 - Fourth year of medical study

62.29±11.47

57.30±6.52

60.75±5.31

1.805

0.176

    

2004 - Fifth year of medical study

62.29±12.10

59.40±4.52

61.88±5.35

0.748

0.479

    

2005 - Sixth year of medical study

60.14±14.64

59.40±4.52

61.50±5.59

0.255

0.776

    
  1. *p<0.05; **p<0.01; ***p<0.001