From: Effectiveness of simulation-based nursing education depending on fidelity: a meta-analysis
Author (Year) | Country | Random assignment | Sample size experimental/control | Level of fidelity | Expertise-level of students |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tosterud (2013) | Norway | Y | 29/28 | HFS | 1-3year |
Alfes (2011) | USA | Y | 29/34 | HFS | 1 year |
Andrighetti (2011) | USA | Y | 9/5 | HFS | graduate |
Johnson (2012) | USA | Y | 19/16 | HFS | graduate |
LeFlore (2007) | USA | N | 5/5 | HFS | NP students |
Maneval (2012) | USA | Y | 13/13 | HFS | graduate |
Parker (2011) | USA | Y | 18/23 | HFS | 2 year |
Shepherd (2010) | UK | Y | 9/15 | HFS | 3 year |
Smith (2012) | USA | Y | 16/17 | HFS | 3 year |
Smith (2013) | USA | N | 36/20 | HFS | 4 year |
Thomas (2012) | USA | N | 14/10 | HFS | 3-4year |
White (2013) | USA | Y | 16/38 | HFS | 4 year |
Brannan (2008) | USA | N | 54/53 | HFS | |
Kwon (2012) | Korea | Y | 19/19 | HFS | nurse |
Kim, D. H. (2012) | Korea | N | 69/62 | HFS | 4 year |
Kim, S. A. (2012) | Korea | N | 103/68 | HFS | 3 year |
Kim (2011) | Korea | N | 26/24 | HFS | nurse |
Yang (2008) | Korea | N | 92/75 | HFS | 2 year |
Yang (2012) | Korea | N | 94/91 | HFS | 3 year |
Lee (2010) | Korea | Y | 35/34 | HFS | 1 year |
Choi, E. H. (2013) | Korea | Y | 32/33 | HFS | 2 year |
Ha (2012) | Korea | Y | 60/58 | HFS | 3 year |
Heo (2012) | Korea | Y | 26/31 | HFS | 3 year |
Lee (2013) | Korea | Y | 96/84 | SP/LFS | 2 year |
Lee (2009) | Korea | N | 141/142 | SP/HFS | 1 year |
Chang (2002) | China | Y | 14/14 | LFS | nurses |
Shepherd (2007) | Australia | Y | 23/25 | LFS | nurses |
Weiner (2011) | USA | Y | 23/23 | LFS | nurses |
Alinier (2006) | UK | Y | 49/50 | MFS | 2 year |
Chang (2010) | Korea | Y | 20/20 | MFS | nurse |
Becker (2006) | USA | Y | 47/82 | SP | 4 year |
Foley (1997) | USA | N | 28/38 | SP | nurses |
Khadivzadeh (2012) | Iran | Y | 28/28 | SP | midwifery students |
Kim, S. H. (2012) | Korea | N | 29/25 | SP | 3 year |
Roh (2013) | Korea | N | 35/39 | SP | nurse |
Park (2012) | Korea | Y | 23/21 | SP | 4 year |
Eom (2010) | Korea | N | 31/31 | SP | 2&4 year |
Lee (2011) | Korea | N | 20/18 | SP | 2 year |
Cho (2012) | Korea | Y | 19/19 | SP | nurse |
Choi, S. J. (2013) | Korea | N | 22/22 | SP | 3 year |