Teaching trainers to incorporate evidence-based medicine (EBM) teaching in clinical practice: the EU-EBM project
© Thangaratinam et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2009
Received: 31 October 2008
Accepted: 10 September 2009
Published: 10 September 2009
Evidence based medicine (EBM) is considered an integral part of medical training, but integration of teaching various EBM steps in everyday clinical practice is uncommon. Currently EBM is predominantly taught through theoretical courses, workshops and e-learning. However, clinical teachers lack confidence in teaching EBM in workplace and are often unsure of the existing opportunities for teaching EBM in the clinical setting. There is a need for continuing professional development (CPD) courses that train clinical trainers to teach EBM through on-the-job training by demonstration of applied EBM real time in clinical practice. We developed such a course to encourage clinically relevant teaching of EBM in post-graduate education in various clinical environments.
We devised an e-learning course targeting trainers with EBM knowledge to impart educational methods needed to teach application of EBM teaching in commonly used clinical settings. The curriculum development group comprised experienced EBM teachers, clinical epidemiologists, clinicians and educationalists from institutions in seven European countries. The e-learning sessions were designed to allow participants (teachers) to undertake the course in the workplace during short breaks within clinical activities. An independent European steering committee provided input into the process.
The curriculum defined specific learning objectives for teaching EBM by exploiting educational opportunities in six different clinical settings. The e-modules incorporated video clips that demonstrate practical and effective methods of EBM teaching in everyday clinical practice. The course encouraged focussed teaching activities embedded within a trainer's personal learning plan and documentation in a CPD portfolio for reflection.
This curriculum will help senior clinicians to identify and make the best use of available opportunities in everyday practice in clinical situations to teach various steps of EBM and demonstrate their applicability to clinical practice. Once fully implemented, the ultimate outcome of this pilot project will be a European qualification in teaching EBM, which will be used by doctors, hospitals, professional bodies responsible for postgraduate qualifications and continuing medical education.
Evidence-based medicine (EBM) is considered to be the most ethical way to practice medicine as it integrates research into clinical practice. It has evolved into a powerful tool for well informed decision-making within the clinician's daily practice. The challenge is to teach it practically in a clinical setting [1–4]. Unless trainees practice EBM in everyday clinical work and observe their teachers practice EBM it will be difficult for EBM to achieve the status of core competency in medicine. To develop effective on-the-job training requires clinical teachers to develop the confidence to explicitly demonstrate to trainees how their daily decisions about healthcare are based on the best available, current, valid and relevant evidence . For this, they need to move their trainees forward from standalone courses, which may be effective in improving EBM knowledge, to clinically integrate work-based teaching and learning that can bring about changes in skills, attitudes and behaviour [5, 6]. How can senior clinicians develop competence in teaching integration of good quality research evidence into clinical practice?
Through our EU EBM Unity project we had successfully devised a clinically integrated EBM e-learning course targeting the learners of EBM [7, 8]. The publication of this project was "Highly Accessed" at Bio Med Central . Often the knowledge and skills attained by the EBM learners from courses like the above fell into decline due to lack of opportunities to continue EBM practice in their clinical environment. During the development of our EBM course for learners, we became aware of the need to equip trainers with practical teaching skills to teach trainees the use of EBM in various clinical activities. There is a need to develop continuing professional development (CPD) courses aimed at clinical teachers based on the sound principles of effective continuing education. No such courses currently exist for teaching the trainers effective methods for teaching and demonstrating integration of EBM to their trainees in a clinical setting. This background led us to develop a clinically integrated course for the teachers of EBM who supervise postgraduate medical training. This paper describes the process of curriculum development along with its current results.
Funded by the European Union (EU) through the Lifelong learning programme 2007 Leonardo da Vinci Transfer of innovation pilot project, we designed an e-learning curriculum for CPD that would encourage participants (trainers) to learn practical and effective teaching methods for tutoring application of EBM in various clinical settings. The EU EBM TTT partnership involves a collaboration of 10 partners within Europe and contributes to harmonisation of EBM learning and teaching across the European healthcare sector http://www.ebm-unity.org.
We developed the curriculum for teachers using sound educational principles for effective adult learning allowing a maximum of flexibility and relevance to clinical practice [9–11]. A curriculum committee consisting of experts in the field of EBM, clinical epidemiologists, clinicians and educationalists from the participating countries contributed to the work. Our methodology for the curriculum design included identification of learning needs in each partner country, formulation of the aims, objectives and learning outcomes, development and organisation of the content of the curriculum, development of the teaching methods, definition of the educational strategy and educational environment, and delineation of an assessment strategy.
In addition to our working group, an independent European Steering Committee provided input into the content, educational approach, applicability and sustainability, giving advice at critical stages in the curriculum development and thereby assured external validation and triangulation of the syllabus prepared.
Identification of learning needs of EBM trainers
To begin with we identified specific educational opportunities in various clinical settings that can be exploited by trainers to teach application of EBM. We took into account the variation in clinical settings and teaching opportunities in different countries along with the variation in the level of EBM knowledge amongst the trainers and trainees. This was done by an in-depth discussion among the project partners who had a good overview of the ongoing activities in their countries, with input from the external steering committee. We performed a survey to identify the commonly perceived obstacles for teaching EBM in clinical practice. The feedback from trainers in our earlier work showed that there was a considerable demand for up-skilling trainers . The above process helped to define feasible educational goals for the documented learning needs of clinical trainers.
Formulation of objectives and learning outcomes of teaching the EBM trainers course
The aim of the e-course was to provide trainers with practical tips and methods by which EBM can be taught during a range of clinical activities. The course had a large e-learning component providing practical demonstration of techniques to teach EBM to clinical trainees . E-learning sessions were designed to allow learning in the workplace during short breaks within clinical activities, with the option to interrupt and restart learning flexibly. The learning objectives and outcomes were to help participants identify their trainees' knowledge gaps related to current clinical practice and to use these to initiate EBM teaching (Appendix). This would allow them to teach the trainees to follow the key steps of EBM in practice. They would generate structured questions in an appropriate format in any clinical setting e.g. during ward round, outpatient clinics, case discussion meeting, etc. Trainers should be able to guide the trainees to search for relevant literature, aiming for and identifying systematic reviews wherever possible by helping them choose the relevant search terms and directing them towards appropriate databases with input from a medical librarian if possible . They should be able to teach the trainee to assess the quality (validity) of systematic reviews and the primary research included within them, emphasising that rather than being a statistical exercise it is actually an exercise towards bridging the gap between research and practice . They should be able to demonstrate the applicability of the research findings to current clinical practice. Finally, they should encourage the trainees to evaluate and eventually adapt current practice in the light of newer evidences through clinically relevant activities like audit or quality assurance . These key issues guided the development of the curriculum in six modules. Each module exploited learning and teaching opportunity presented at various clinical settings and provided practical tip to teach the key steps of EBM.
Content of modules
Learning opportunities for teaching evidence based medicine (EBM) in clinical practice
Searching for Evidence
Integrating Evidence with Clinical scenario
Bringing Change to Practice
Clinical Teaching And Assessment
Formal Clinical Meeting
Ward rounds: These are usually undertaken by a senior clinician with trainees, nurses and if feasible clinical librarian
Journal club: It is a regular educational activity where the clinician, often a trainee critically appraises a published piece of evidence obtained by systematic search of literature to answer a clinical question
Formal clinical meetings: Any meeting attended by the trainer or trainee from one or more disciplines where the management of individual cases are discussed
Outpatient clinic: The management of patients on an outpatient basis by the trainer and trainee
Audit meeting: It is a formal meeting usually held in a hospital where current clinical practice is compared to predetermined standards of care
Formal clinical assessment: It is usually a one to one meeting between the trainer and the trainee where the trainer assesses the clinical knowledge and skills of the trainee using validated assessment tools
Teaching opportunities during clinical encounters were taught through two modules focussing on ward rounds and outpatient clinics . These two clinical settings are the commonest available opportunities for interaction between the trainer and trainee. The first EBM step, question formulation, can easily be taught here. The module helps the teacher to expose knowledge gaps in the trainee by asking questions relevant to the patient seen in the clinic or ward and framing them as focussed question using the PICO format. It guides the trainer how to prescribe an educational prescription which can be quickly handed to a trainee for them to follow it up when an opportunity arises during their busy schedule . In institutions where there are facilities to perform immediate searches, a clinical librarian or another colleague can demonstrate the ways in which trainees can search in appropriate databases using relevant search terms to obtain evidence.
Opportunities to teach EBM during clinical meetings were covered in three modules using Journal club, Morbidity and Mortality meetings, and Audit presentations [16, 20, 21]. These occasions engage trainees in communal EBM activity. These meetings offer the trainee the chance to prepare in advance before the event. The modules illustrate with the help of video demonstration and slides, the role of the teacher in providing the trainee with information and material on the literature searching and critical appraisal steps of EBM. Journal clubs are ideal opportunities to teach in depth critical appraisal of papers presented with help from easy to use software for EBM calculations [20, 21]. At morbidity and mortality meetings, in addition to obtaining and appraising the relevant evidence, the ways in which the applicability of that evidence to the care of the individual patient can also be illustrated. The use of Audit meetings in teaching the final step in EBM, bringing change to clinical practice, can be demonstrated .
Clinical assessment of trainees are ideal opportunities for the teacher to provide formative or summative assessment of EBM competence and for giving feedback on their performance [13, 22]. These assessments are carried using different tools in different countries. The module also provided examples of assessment tools used in different European countries.
Administration of the course and learning method
Our systematic review of existing assessment tools has not identified specific assessment tools for evaluating effectiveness of teaching the teachers courses in EBM We therefore developed and validated a questionnaire to assess the participants' performance before and after completion of the course. They will be assessed on their knowledge, skills and attitude using specific questions in a multiple choice format. The course has been piloted in 5 EU countries involving 60 participants. During the piloting we have collected feedback from the participants on the content of course material, ease of access, clarity of information provided using semi structured qualitative interviews. We have evaluated the technology acceptance using a validated Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) questionnaire. The results of these will enable further improvement of the course to suit the specific needs of participants.
Through this EU project we have established an e-learning course targeting EBM teachers with emphasis on its piloting and promotion across the European healthcare sector and beyond.
It is well known that effective learning occurs when learners link theory with practice. This implies that learners are able to make connections between knowledge gained in one scenario and apply it to another . They are able to achieve this by identifying and exploiting the educational opportunities available in daily clinical practice learnt through the course to teach integration of EBM. This curriculum will help senior clinicians to make the best use of available opportunities in everyday clinical situations to teach about the various steps of EBM and their application to practice, using the principles of adult learning. It will contribute to their professional development and will improve their educational environment.
The e-curriculum for trainers satisfies the CRISIS criteria for successful CPD . It is developed in such a way that it is Convenient (C) for the trainer to learn integration of EBM teaching in clinical practice by working through the modules in a setting and time of their choice. To our knowledge at the moment such a curriculum aimed at this target population does not exist. By showing the teaching opportunities in various clinical settings encountered by any healthcare professional in day-to-day practice, it is highly Relevant (R) to this group of individuals. The curriculum is Individualised (I) with flexibility to apply the principles of teaching in various clinical settings, medical disciplines and countries. Where possible every effort has been made to ensure that the variations in healthcare system across the EU countries are taken into account during the curriculum development. At the end of modules, there is the prospect of Self-assessment (S) of the participants to evaluate their knowledge and competency in teaching EBM. The assessment tools have been developed and validated and has been piloted in the partner countries. Use of short segments of slides combined with video clip recordings of the actual EBM teaching in various clinical set up is aimed at arousing the Interest (I) of the learner. By highlighting the differences in clinical practice, teaching techniques, available resources and educational culture we have attempted to Speculate (S) on difficult and controversial areas of the course. The entire e-curriculum is devised in such a way that the learning process is Systematic (S) with specific aims, learning objectives, content and summary for each module.
The use of the curriculum may be limited by the differences in clinical settings, EBM knowledge, resources and attitudes in various institutions and countries. The examples provided in the modules are limited to articles on therapy. With increasing use of the modules in various countries will help in further development with necessary adaptations as required.
The goal of this project is to help clinical trainers identify opportunities to teach trainees integration of EBM, provide them with tips to perform this in various clinical settings and to raise awareness about this curriculum for trainers throughout Europe and ultimately incorporate it in mainstream curriculum. The dissemination systems in place such as the website, presentations on national conferences and workshops, word of mouth and publications in national language will allow access, discussion and dissemination of the results. The project partners are exploring ways to involve their national networks of institutions that might benefit from the process.
Currently in this project we have covered ways to teach EBM in six clinical settings. Furthermore to complement our previous project on EBM curriculum, we have provided examples using systematic reviews of therapy. We are translating the course in six languages. In the future, we plan to increase the number of modules to cover other clinical settings not currently included, provide examples using diagnostic and prognostic studies and make the curriculum relevant to healthcare professionals other than doctors.
The EU EBM Training the Trainers curriculum will help senior clinicians to identify and make the best use of available opportunities in everyday practice in clinical situations to teach various steps of EBM and demonstrate their applicability to clinical practice. Complete application of this pilot project aimed at teachers of EBM will be a European qualification in teaching EBM, which will be used by senior doctors, hospitals and professional bodies responsible for postgraduate qualifications and continuing medical education. The EU EBM Training the Trainers project will lead the way in bringing about teaching EBM closer to everyday clinical practice with the prospect of improving patient care.
Appendix: An overview of e-EBM Training the Trainers continuing professional development (CPD) course
To provide guidance on practical and effective methods to teach clinically integrated evidence based medicine (EBM) in various clinical settings
Senior health professionals in a clinical setting with responsibility for teaching and training.
exposing knowledge gaps in the trainees that leads to construction of structured question
seeking information from trainees on how they will track the best evidence to answer the question
developing confidence in number crunching to interpret the results
effectively using various clinical opportunities to teach critical appraisal of literature
demonstrating how clinical judgement is used to determine the extent to which research evidence can be applied for individual patient care
enabling trainees to present and discuss in formal clinical meetings by applying the steps of EBM
Participants to pursue independent study by using the following e-learning modules to obtain CPD or continuing medical education (CME) credits
E-learning modules with demonstration videos
Module 1: Ward Rounds
Module 2: Journal Club
Module 3: Clinical assessment
Module 4: Outpatients Clinic
Module 5: Formal Clinical Meeting
Module 6: Audit
Questionnaire and log of teaching activities in a personal learning plan
- Dawes M, Summerskill W, Glaziou P, Cartabellotta A, Martin J, Hopayian K, et al: Sicily statement on evidence-based practice. BMC Med Educ. 2005, 5: 1-10.1186/1472-6920-5-1.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hatala R, Keitz SA, Wilson MC, Guyatt G: Beyond journal clubs. Moving toward an integrated evidence-based medicine curriculum. J Gen Intern Med. 2006, 21: 538-541. 10.1111/j.1525-1497.2006.00445.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Khan K, Coomarasamy A: A hierarchy of effective teaching and learning to acquire competence in evidenced-based medicine. BMC Medical Education. 2006, 6: 59-10.1186/1472-6920-6-59.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Korenstein D, Dunn A, McKinn T: Mixing it up:integrating evidence-based medicine and patient care. Acad Med. 2002, 77: 741-742. 10.1097/00001888-200207000-00028.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Coomarasamy A, Khan KS: What is the evidence that postgraduate teaching in evidence based medicine changes anything? A systematic review. BMJ. 2004, 329: 1017-10.1136/bmj.329.7473.1017.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Del Mar Chris, Glasziou Paul, Mayer Dan: Teaching evidence based medicine should be integrated into current clinical scenarios. BMJ. 2004, 329: 989-990. 10.1136/bmj.329.7473.989.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Coppus SF, Emparanza JI, Hadley J, Kulier R, Weinbrenner S, Arvanitis TN, et al: A clinically integrated Curriculum in Evidence-based Medicine for just-in-time learning through on-the-job training: The EU-EBM project 1. BMC Med Educ. 2007, 7: 46-10.1186/1472-6920-7-46.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kulier R, Hadley J, Weinbrenner S, Meyerrose B, Decsi T, Horvath A, et al: Harmonising Evidence-based medicine teaching: a study of the outcomes of e-learning in five European countries. BMC Medical Education. 2008, 8: 27-10.1186/1472-6920-8-27.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Harden RM: Ten questions to ask when planning a course or curriculum. Med Educ. 1986, 20: 356-365. 10.1111/j.1365-2923.1986.tb01379.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Harden RM, Laidlaw JM: Effective continuing education: the CRISIS criteria. Med Educ. 1992, 26: 408-422. 10.1111/j.1365-2923.1992.tb00194.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Knowles MS: Andragogy in action: Applying modern principles of adult learning. 1984, San Francisco: Jossey-BassGoogle Scholar
- Kulier R, Hadley J, Weinbrenner S, Meyerrose B, Decsi T, Horvath AR, et al: Harmonising evidence-based medicine teaching: a study of the outcomes of e-learning in five European countries. BMC Med Educ. 2008, 8: 27-10.1186/1472-6920-8-27.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Das K, Malick S, Khan KS: Tips for teaching evidence-based medicine in a clinical setting: lessons from adult learning theory. Part one. J R Soc Med. 2008, 101: 493-500. 10.1258/jrsm.2008.080712.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Deshpande N, Publicover M, Gee H, Khan KS: Incorporating the views of obstetric clinicians in implementing evidence-supported labour and delivery suite ward rounds: a case study. Health Info Libr J. 2003, 20: 86-94. 10.1046/j.1471-1842.2003.00422.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Coomarasamy A, Latthe P, Papaioannou S, Publicover M, Gee H, Khan KS: Critical appraisal in clinical practice: sometimes irrelevant, occasionally invalid. J R Soc Med. 2001, 94: 573-577.Google Scholar
- Kulier R, Gee H, Khan KS: Five steps from evidence to effect: exercising clinical freedom to implement research findings. BJOG. 2008, 115: 1197-1202. 10.1111/j.1471-0528.2008.01821.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Davis J, Chryssafidou E, Zamora J, Davies D, Khan K, Coomarasamy A: Computer-based teaching is as good as face to face lecture-based teaching of evidence based medicine: a randomised controlled trial. BMC Med Educ. 2007, 7: 23-10.1186/1472-6920-7-23.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Davis J, Crabb S, Rogers E, Zamora J, Khan K: Computer-based teaching is as good as face to face lecture-based teaching of evidence based medicine: a randomized controlled trial. Med Teach. 2008, 30: 302-307. 10.1080/01421590701784349.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sackett DL, Straus S, Richardson WS, Rosenberg W, Haynes B: Evidence-Based Medicine. How to Practice and Teach EBM. 2000, Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 2Google Scholar
- Khan KS, Gee H: A new approach to teaching and learning in journal club. Medical Teacher. 1999, 21: 289-293. 10.1080/01421599979554.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Khan KS, Bachmann LM, Steurer J: The Medical Journal Club - A Tool for Knowledge Refinement and Transfer in Healthcare. Knowledge Media in Healthcare: Opportunities and Challenges. 2001, 176-186.Google Scholar
- Hatala R, Keitz SA, Wilson MC, Guyatt G: Beyond journal clubs. Moving toward an integrated evidence-based medicine curriculum. J Gen Intern Med. 2006, 21: 538-541. 10.1111/j.1525-1497.2006.00445.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wyer PC, Keitz S, Hatala R, Hayward R, Barratt A, et al: Tips for learning and teaching evidence-based medicine: introduction to the series. CMAJ. 2004, 171: 347-348.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kolb DA: Experiential Learning:experience as the source of learning and development. 1984, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6920/9/59/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.